This person's 16 Official Information requests
ET Internal Comms, Discussing Public Excess Deaths Analysis
Follow up sent to Health New Zealand by M Bell on .
Long overdue.
I struggle to accept the claim that 18(f) applies, as office 365 could easily filter and provide output for this communication.
Please refine the re...
Pfizer Covid Vaccine Risk Benefit Analysis / Risk-Benefit Asessment
Partially successful.
'This includes
the assessment of results from clinical trials to help demonstrate the
efficacy and safety of the vaccines,'
What of process 1/proce...
MoH ET Internal Comms, Discussing Excess Deaths Analysis
Response by Ministry of Health to M Bell on .
Partially successful.
Kia ora Mark,
Please find attached a response to your official information act request.
Ngā mihi
OIA Services Team
Manatū Hauora | Minist...
Statements by Margie Apa about Whistleblowers Vaccine Data
Follow up sent to Health New Zealand by M Bell on .
Information not held.
Thankyou for confirmation that there is no further information to provide. The request is now marked as “information not held” and I have withdrawn t...
Request refused, no such document(s) or correspondence could be found.
According to Steve Kirsch both scientists have viewed the leaked data, furtherm...
The covid 19 pandemic "full scale, wide ranging, independent inquiry conducted publicly..."
Response by Winston Peters to M Bell on .
Refused.
Dear M Bell,
Please see the attached letter from Minister van Velden in response to
your OIA request.
Kind regards,
Cami
Office of Hon...
Kia ora M Bell
Thank you for your request under the Official Information Act 1982 (the
Act) on 1 February 2024, following up on a response to your pr...
So what can we actually do? Sadly people are still taking it (not many by sounds) but it is criminal and they need to be saved from themselves firstly...
Minister of Finance Indemnity Documents in Relation to Influenza Vaccine
Response by Nicola Willis to M Bell on .
Partially successful.
Dear M Bell
On behalf of Hon Nicola Willis, Minister of Finance, thank you for your further email.
I can advise that the confidentiality clauses stil...
Request for Proactive Release of Cabinet Documents Relating to Vaccine Aquisition
Response by Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet to M Bell on .
Successful.
Tēnā koe,
Thank you for emailing the Department of the Prime Minister and
Cabinet (DPMC), including the National Emergency Management
Agency (...
Leaked Data on Covid Vaccine Excess Deaths
Follow up sent to Shane Reti by M Bell on .
Information not held.
I have looked at all of the information that you have provided and I did not find any indication that any analysis has been done to rebut the leaked...
MBIE Key Messaging Details on Pfizer Indemnity Issue
Response by Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment to M Bell on .
Successful.
Good evening M Bell,
Please see attached for MBIE’s letter to your Official Information Act
request.
Kind regards,
Lisa
Lisa Seng...
Procurement Documentation C19 Vaccine Purchases
Response by Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment to M Bell on .
Successful.
Good evening M Bell,
Please see attached for MBIE’s letter to your Official Information Act
request.
Apologies for this late information r...
CV-ISMB all available Meeting Minutes, Rapid Cycle Analysis Reports
Response by Ministry of Health to M Bell on .
Partially successful.
Kia ora M Bell,
CV ISMB Minutes
Please note that the error was made from our side and we apologise for the
inconvenience and confusion thi...
Epidemiologist Response to Steve Kisch Excess Death Analysis.
Response by Health New Zealand to M Bell on .
Information not held.
Kia ora M Bell
Thank you for your request for information regarding Epidemiologist
response to excess death analysis on 11 December. Please find...
Track Record of Confidentiality for NZ Census Data
Response by Statistics New Zealand to M Bell on .
Successful.
Kia ora M Bell
I appreciate you getting in touch so promptly to confirm this with us and I am happy to hear that the response is satisfactory.
Ngā m...
This person's 26 annotations
MoH ET Internal Comms, Discussing Excess Deaths Analysis
Partially successful.
Update to the ombudsman complaint in progress...
MoH have promised the response, but still waiting, waiting.
MoH have stated to the ombudsman that (a...
Request refused, no such document(s) or correspondence could be found.
According to Steve Kirsch both scientists have viewed the leaked data, furtherm...
Agree Chris. It is pretty clear Kirsch is correct in his analysis, and it is all publicly available on his substack (https://kirschsubstack.com/). HNZ...
Statements by Margie Apa about Whistleblowers Vaccine Data
Information not held.
Complaint made to the ombudsman.
Pfizer Covid Vaccine Risk Benefit Analysis / Risk-Benefit Asessment
Partially successful.
It appears from the only specific document provided, that the RISK of COVID mortality was stated to be low, plenty of data was available confirming thi...
Investigator Policy of the Ombudsman
Handled by post.
A successful response would be show some really good transparency from the office of the ombudsman and hence would valuable to be posted publicly into...
Seems outrageous that they are attempting to refuse a simple request about budget details on the grounds of endangering someone. This utter arrogance o...
Relevant considerations - fluoride levels in urine, levels in drinking water - IQ & cognitive harm to children
Long overdue.
Claiming the information requested does not exist is either dishonesty (from someone) or alternatively it is an admission of incompetence at high level...
Total Annual Cases
Long overdue.
Nice work anyway Chris,
We can be pretty sure these agencies all have access to the same data. I previously asked medsafe for 2021 hopitalisation rate...
Chris, re your last request, since you are not asking for official cause of death, it certainly seems pretty clear that deliberate obfuscation of data...
Unfortunately no transparency on any of the questions.
Regarding item 3, the Chris James response makes an appeal to authority with comments like:
“T...
Quantity of aluminium contained in vaccines on the NZ immunisation schedule
Information not held.
Translation of the OIA response: Medsafe knows exactly how much Aluminum is in each of these injections, but they are not going to tell you to protect...
What is the infection fatality rate of Covid 19?
Long overdue.
Seems to be a lot of equivocating of words here risk, rate, case, infection etc. It is astounding that they are claiming that they do not know the infe...
Police Warrant of Operation
Partially successful.
Be interesting what the outcome of the ombudsman investigation is, and am also very interested as to which parts of the response you thought were not c...
Total Annual Cases
Long overdue.
Nice work here Chris, continue to hold their feet to the fire. Agree that it is either obfuscation or incompetence going on here.
Do we LAWFULLY have to pay income tax
Successful.
From the IRD response ... "A person includes an individual; see section AA 3 of the ITA and in Part 2 of the Legislation Act 2019."
This does not appe...
Altered composition of Comirnaty BNT162b2
Awaiting classification.
Ministry of Health quote: “Details regarding quantitative formulations are withheld under 9(2)(b)(ii), as I have considered the countervailing public...
Cessations of safety reports for Comirnaty by Medsafe
Long overdue.
Chris James provides a syllogism on the reasoning to stop the reporting as follows:
“Since the pandemic immunisation response has started reverting b...
Altered composition of Comirnaty BNT162b2
Awaiting classification.
Quote from medsafe: The qualitative formulation for Comirnaty 0.5mg/ml has not changed since its initial approval.
Interesting choice of words, uses...
Employment NZ advice to not answer questions about a medicine's safety
Request to Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment by Erika Whittome. Annotated by M Bell on .
Partially successful.
Quote from that guide to legal privilege ... "A document does not become the subject of legal professional privilege merely because it is signed by a l...
Employment NZ advice to not answer questions about a medicine's safety
Request to Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment by Erika Whittome. Annotated by M Bell on .
Partially successful.
"Redactions have been made under section 9(2)(h) to maintain legal
professional privilege between officials and their legal advisors."
Might be a goo...
Miscarriage - Spontaneous Abortion - Abortion Missed
Awaiting classification.
Note for you: Hospitalisations for spontaneous abortion / miscarriage in 2021 were 2498 as per the OIA request received from medsafe. This was up from...
Source of background rate used in CARM reports
Successful.
Very interesting that in the OIA I have been supplied there are some other very significant hospitalisations are hugely up from the stated background r...
Source of background rate used in CARM reports
Successful.
Well the 2021 actual hospitalisation rates that they supplied to me for those conditions were as follows:
Myocarditus 369
Pericarditus 1171
Hope tha...
Source of background rate used in CARM reports
Successful.
I have received an OIA of the actual AESI hospitalisations from 2021, giving a reasonable comparison at least to report 39. https://www.medsafe.govt.nz...