Luke C
Joined FYI in 2013
Happy to assist requesters in composing their OIA requests to make them clear and intelligible to agencies. And an interest in assisting requesters on how best they can get the information they need.
Also interested in:
- organisations' internal processes, procedures, and practices, for dealing with the processing, handling and refusal of OIA requests.
- the existence of any legal tests to fulfil the statutory withholding provisions.
Sign in to change password, subscriptions and more (Luke C only)
This person's 231 annotations (page 2)
Ratings Information for the OnDemand Series, BossBabes, and How OnDemand Views are Counted
Successful.
Hi Alex
How will this information assist you?
Privacy reports
Waiting clarification.
The agency is seeking to make contact with the requester to assumingly refine the request. Has the requester availed themselves by making their phone n...
Request for safety testing results for 5G
Awaiting classification.
Only point 1 of the requester's request is a request for official information. The rest of the email is espousing a view.
ZX Security
Partially successful.
Are the redactions appropriate? I'm not suggesting they are not.
Privacy reports
Waiting clarification.
Quite broad
NZTA Board Minutes and CEO Reports (2019/05/27 Request)
Partially successful.
They don't specifically address your part of the request for the chief executive's report, but I assume that the report will be considered as part of t...
E-mail communications
Successful.
I don't agree that re-scoping the request would be onerous. They haven't supplied any figures to indicate the volume of emails received across, say, a...
All information pertaining to me
Information not held.
Elaine, you could be a lot more helpful. Let's hope TVNZ can identify some appropriate internal information sources to search that may contain your per...
429 State sector boards and committees
Successful.
The page was last updated 29 Nov 2016 (refer to the bottom).
The Ministry for Women is a small ministry and as such probably does not have the resou...
Taito Phillip Field
Successful.
Mr Rogers: Under 17(2)(a) of the OIA, would the Parole Board not have to state the reasons for the withholding of the location of the meeting and names...
All information pertaining to me
Information not held.
Elaine: The advice from the Citizens Advice Bureau is correct. However TVNZ's angle is not asking you why you want it, they are asking you in what cont...
Thompson & Clark
Partially successful.
I do find the withholding of the letter from Doug Martin of behalf of the State Services Commission to be strange. I'm sure the content would not preju...
Library wage levels
Successful.
At least you got an answer twice than none at all!
Photos taken in Wellington on 9-13 October
Successful.
It would be interesting to know whether all 166 photographs and 21 video clips of various length are included on the DVDs.
What was the Ombudsman's r...
Do Maori own the Reserve Bank of New Zealand? Why does it have a Maori Head on the coat of arms?
Successful.
Nowhere in the links you provide does it say the bank is "completely independent". It says it has "statutory independence" which means it carries out i...
Seat kilometres per day of electric buses
Successful.
Thanks David for the explanation.
Aviation Security (Avsec) Effectiveness
Successful.
I agree with Cody.
I am not sure that withholding the information meets the test of s6(a)*. It would be interesting to see what the Ombudsman had to...
Seat kilometres per day of electric buses
Successful.
What do you mean by "seat kilometres"?
Determining level of general staff positions
Awaiting classification.
To expand on Duanna's response, I can add:
1. Key staff in the HR Team that manage job evaluations are likely to hold a copy of the "SP10 Job Evaluat...
Those are quite reasonable points Andrew.
In respect of the Ministry's decision to withhold document 6 under section 9(2)(h), I agree with your publi...
Howard
Like I said in an earlier response, your best bet is to make a complaint to the Ombudsman for them to review the Board's determination that yo...
RBNZ Governor Recruitment Process
Successful.
I am very disappointed that the Bank erred in its original decision as it was such an egregiously incorrect decision. In addition, the overly lengthy t...
Communications between Melissa Lee and Richard Griffin
Information not held.
Good points, Oliver
I'm left wondering if the requests referred to in the second paragraph of the letter are essentially Privacy Act requests, asking for private informati...
Official Residence of the Deputy Prime Minster
Partially successful.
Your request was answered to the extent that the Department said that it is a property in Bolton St, Wellington, but it wasn't clear whether it was Cro...
