Provision of communication between Kapiti Coast District Council and others in respect of Number 4 Elizabeth Street and the Waikanae Chartered Club
Alan Moule made this Official Information request to Kapiti Coast District Council
This request has an unknown status. We're waiting for Alan Moule to read recent responses and update the status.
From: Alan Moule
Dear Kapiti Coast District Council,
Please provide all communication (internal and external) between the Kapiti Coast District Council BCA/TA functions, Infrastructure, Property, Planning and members of the Waikanae Chartered Club, notably Michael (Mike) Cardiff, the Chair and any officer of Waikanae Chartered Club and Nicky Holden, or her team (Property), Shaun Mallon, or his team (Infrastructure), Steven Cody, or his team (BCA/TA) in respect of 4 Elizabeth Street including the possible sale and purchase of the KCDC land providing access to the rear of number 4 (identifier 625861, Section 1 Survey Office Plan 35434) and all communication relating to the proposed development of Number 4 Elizabeth Street, Waikanae.
Yours faithfully,
Alan Moule
Owner Number 4 Elizabeth Street
From: Mailbox - Information Request
Kapiti Coast District Council
Good afternoon Alan,
Thank you for your email yesterday, 27 October 2021. Your request will be
managed under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act
1987 (LGOIMA (the Act).
We will do our best to get a response to you by 24 November 2021, this
being the statutory 20 working days after your request was received. Your
request is being handled by our Strategy, Growth and Recovery team. Please
note, the reference for your request is OIR 2122-108.
Your request asked for the following:
Please provide all communication (internal and external) between the
Kapiti Coast District Council BCA/TA functions, Infrastructure, Property,
Planning and members of the Waikanae Chartered Club, notably Michael
(Mike) Cardiff, the Chair and any officer of Waikanae Chartered Club and
Nicky Holden, or her team (Property), Shaun Mallon, or his team
(Infrastructure), Steven Cody, or his team (BCA/TA) in respect of 4
Elizabeth Street including the possible sale and purchase of the KCDC land
providing access to the rear of number 4 (identifier 625861, Section 1
Survey Office Plan 35434) and all communication relating to the proposed
development of Number 4 Elizabeth Street, Waikanae.
Refinement of your request
Staff have considered the work involved in collating the information to
answer your request for ‘all communication (internal and external)”
pertaining to 4 Elizabeth Street and have concluded that it will take a
considerable amount of time to collate the information and consider
whether it can be released, it is possible that there could be hundreds if
not thousands of records relevant to this address and the people you have
listed in your request.
I am therefore writing to you to invite you to refine the scope of your
request to be more specific about the information you are seeking. For
example, can you tell us whether you would like to receive information for
a specific period of time, it is helpful for us to have some parameters to
search within.
Further items of note
1. When we receive your refined request, we will need to consider whether
processing the request could incur a charge. Please find details about
our fees and charges via the following link:
[1]https://www.kapiticoast.govt.nz/services....
If a charge is applicable, we will inform you of the estimated cost
and seek approval from you to proceed further.
2. We will also consider whether we would be able to respond to your
request given extra time, an extension for the response may be
applied, unless it would significantly impact Council’s ability to
undertake its day to day work.
3. In instances where requests encompass a wide timeframe and require
large amounts of information to be searched, legislation can enable
Council to refuse such a request under section 17(f) of the Act as
“the information requested cannot be made available without
substantial collation or research”.
Please contact us via email on: [2][Kapiti Coast District Council request email]
by 12 noon Monday 1 November 2021 to confirm how you would like to
proceed.
I look forward to hearing from you.
Kind regards
Diane Nattrass
Advisor Official Information
Kâpiti Coast District Council
Tel 04 296 4699
www.kapiticoast.govt.nz
show quoted sections
From: Alan Moule
Dear Diane,
Good to talk to you today.
Following our conversation I wish to reduce the scope in regards the time frame I am interested in.
Please amended my request as below:
Please provide all communication (internal and external), between the dates of 01 January 2021 and today, 4 November 2021, between the Kapiti Coast District Council BCA/TA functions, Infrastructure, Property, Planning and members of the Waikanae Chartered Club, notably Michael (Mike) Cardiff, the Chair and any officer of Waikanae Chartered Club and Nicky Holden, or her team (Property), Shaun Mallon, or his team (Infrastructure), Steven Cody, or his team (BCA/TA) in respect of 4 Elizabeth Street including the possible sale and purchase of the KCDC land providing access to the rear of number 4 (identifier 625861, Section 1 Survey Office Plan 35434) and all communication relating to the proposed
development of Number 4 Elizabeth Street, Waikanae.
Yours sincerely,
Alan Moule
From: Mailbox - Information Request
Kapiti Coast District Council
Dear Alan,
Thank you very much for refining your request to the date range of 01
January 2021 and today, 4 November 2021.
We have undertaken a new records search and identified there is still
significant amounts of correspondence to process. We will therefore do
our best to get a response to you by 4 December 2021, this being the
statutory 20 working days after your refined request was received on 4
November 2021. Your request is being handled by our Strategy, Growth and
Recovery team. Please note, the reference for your request is OIR
2122-108.
Kind regards
Lisa White
Official Information (Acting)
Kāpiti Coast District Council
[1][IMG]
[2][IMG]
[3]www.kapiticoast.govt.nz
[4][IMG]
show quoted sections
From: Mailbox - Information Request
Kapiti Coast District Council
Good afternoon Alan,
As you know we are working on the response to your request for information
related to 4 Elizabeth Street and Waikanae Chartered Club. We had hoped to
have a response out to you today, however, due to staff constraints and
some staff being called in at late notice to work on Council’s response to
the Covid-19 protection framework protocols we will have to extend the
date of our response to you to close of business Wednesday 15 December
2021.
We have the information collated and have been working on the necessary
redactions etc. We just have to go through some final steps before we can
send the information to you, we’re almost there, we just need a little
extra time.
I will be in touch in the coming days.
Kind regards
Diane Nattrass
Advisor Official Information
Tel 04 296 4699
[1][IMG]
[2][IMG]
[3]www.kapiticoast.govt.nz
[4][IMG]
The material in this email is confidential to the individual or entity
named above, and may be protected by legal privilege. If you are not the
intended recipient please do not copy, use or disclose any information
included in this communication without Kāpiti Coast District Council’s
prior permission.
References
Visible links
1. https://www.kapiticoast.govt.nz/our-dist...
2. https://covid19.govt.nz/
3. http://www.kapiticoast.govt.nz/
4. https://www.facebook.com/kapiticoastdist...
From: Mailbox - Information Request
Kapiti Coast District Council
Good afternoon Alan,
As below, yesterday, we tried to send you an email to inform you that we
needed to extend the date of response for your request by another week to
22 December 2021. However, we got a system error and the message likely
never arrived in your inbox or to the FYI address either? Apologies for
this. Please find the official extension email below from Sarah Wattie.
Your message did not reach some or all of the intended recipients.
Subject: Request for information under the LGOIMA - Reference:
OIR 2122-108
Sent: 15/12/2021 7:39 pm
The following recipient(s) cannot be reached:
'[email address]' on 15/12/2021 7:40 pm
Diane Nattrass on 15/12/2021 7:40 pm
This message could not be sent. You do not have the permission
to send the message on behalf of the specified user.
We will be in touch next week. Apologies for the delay we’ve had one hell
of a week here at Council with various issues. Will be glad when it’s the
Christmas break!
Thanks Alan
Kind regards
Diane Nattrass
Advisor Official Information
Kāpiti Coast District Council
Tel 04 296 4699
[1]www.kapiticoast.govt.nz
From: Sarah Wattie On Behalf Of Mailbox - Information Request
Sent: Wednesday, 15 December 2021 7:39 pm
To: '[email address]' <[2][email address]>
Cc: Diane Nattrass <[3][email address]>
Subject: Request for information under the LGOIMA - Reference: OIR
2122-108
Tēnā koe Alan,
We are currently working on your request which is close to being ready for
release; however, unfortunately we will need to request one further
extension until close of business Wednesday 22 December 2021 due to the
amount of information you have requested and the workload within the team
at the moment.
Please do not hesitate to contact us if you have any issues with this
revised timeframe.
Many thanks,
Sarah
Sarah Wattie
Governance & Legal Services Manager
Tel 04 2964 724
[mobile number]
[4][IMG]
[5][IMG]
[6]www.kapiticoast.govt.nz
[7][IMG]
The material in this email is confidential to the individual or entity
named above, and may be protected by legal privilege. If you are not the
intended recipient please do not copy, use or disclose any information
included in this communication without Kāpiti Coast District Council’s
prior permission.
References
Visible links
1. http://www.kapiticoast.govt.nz/
2. mailto:[email address]
3. mailto:[email address]
4. https://www.kapiticoast.govt.nz/our-dist...
5. https://covid19.govt.nz/
6. http://www.kapiticoast.govt.nz/
7. https://www.facebook.com/kapiticoastdist...
From: Alan Moule
Dear Mailbox - Information Request,
Hi Dianne
no problems at all.
Yours sincerely,
Alan Moule
From: Lisa White
Kapiti Coast District Council
Dear Alan,
My sincere apologies. Unfortunately the staff member working on your
request has had to take urgent leave, and reviewing redactions before
management sign-out is difficult without their input/access. I can assure
you that the decision has been to grant your request, it the timing that
is the issue. I will do my utmost to provide this information to you by
Friday 24 December 20201.
FYI - the redactions for review are on the basis of Out of Scope, and
under the following sections of the Act:
• 7(2)(a) – to protect the privacy of natural persons
• 7(2)(g) – to maintain legal professional privilege
• 7(2)(h) – to enable any local authority holding the information to
carry out, without prejudice or disadvantage, commercial activities.
Perhaps if you are not intending to use the file over the holiday period
it would be of great help to me if we could provide by 10th January at the
latest? I am back in the office on the 5th and will make it my priority.
If we do not hear from you we will to continue on the basis that Friday is
the cutoff.
Kind regards, and again my apologies
Lisa White
Kāpiti Coast District Council
show quoted sections
From: Alan Moule
Dear Lisa White,
Thanks for the email. Early January is fine for the information.
Have great Christmas.
Yours sincerely,
Alan Moule
From: Lisa White
Kapiti Coast District Council
Please contact [Kapiti Coast District Council request email] if you have any
queries regarding the Local Government Official Information and Meetings
Act (LGOIMA)
Kind regards,
Lisa White
The material in this email is confidential to the individual or entity
named above, and may be protected by legal privilege. If you are not the
intended recipient please do not copy, use or disclose any information
included in this communication without Kāpiti Coast District Council’s
prior permission.
From: Lisa White
Kapiti Coast District Council
Thank you! Very much appreciated.. You have a great Christmas too.
Lisa White
Contractor to Kāpiti Coast District Council
Kāpiti Coast District Council
Tel 04 296 4455
www.kapiticoast.govt.nz
show quoted sections
From: Mailbox - Information Request
Kapiti Coast District Council
Good afternoon Alan,
Please find attached our response letter and two attachments relating to
your request. You will be able to access the documents via the links at
the bottom of this email (as liquid files). Apologies for all of the
delays and thank you for your patience on this one!
This email is an edited version of the email I sent to your other email
address – for the purposes of it being available on the .fyi website.
Please refer to your personal email for more details.
Listed below are the reasons for you being able to see fully blacked out
pages in the documents. Because these are both large documents, I thought
it was easier to keep the page numbering intact and to avoid any confusion
should anyone need to ask about the document in future.
Hopefully it all makes sense and the documents open for you to view them
with no issues.
Document Reasons for redaction Pages
The following pages are 1 to 7
considered to be either ‘Out of
Scope’ or information is 10 to 13
withheld due to ‘Privacy’
(Section 7(2)(a) of the LGOIMA) 17 to 27
– (inclusive of the numbers
listed) 30 to 32
36
44 to 49
52 to 55
58 to 73
79 to 108
130 to 134
153 to 158
173
176 to 214
4 Elizabeth Street attachment – 253 to 256
338 page document
265 to 266
The following pages are 146
withheld due to ‘Legal
Professional Privilege’ 159
(Section7(2)(g) of the LGOIMA)
- (inclusive of the numbers 161
listed)
164
215 to 216
218 to 219
221 to 222
224
252
257 to 263
265 to 266
287 to 288
294
The following pages are 16 to 20
considered to be either ‘Out of
Scope’ or information is 26
withheld due to ‘Privacy’
(Section 7(2)(a) of the LGOIMA) 34
– (inclusive of the numbers
listed) 36 to 38
43 to 44
47
49 to 75
77 to 78
81 to 88
105
160 to 164
173 to 179
181 to 194
196 to 201
209 to 212
215 to 256
264
273 to 290
300 to 307
Waikanae Chartered attachment –
352 page document 312 to 321
323 to 327
329 to 340
345 to 352
The following pages are 24
withheld due to ‘Legal
Professional Privilege’ 39 to 42
(Section7(2)(g) of the LGOIMA)
- (inclusive of the numbers 45
listed)
76
79
100 to 101
112
165 to 172
180
195
202 to 208
213
257 to 263
265
266 to 272
341 to 344
Please let me know if there are any issues.
Kind regards
Diane Nattrass
Advisor Official Information
Tel 04 296 4699
[1][IMG]
[2][IMG]
[3]www.kapiticoast.govt.nz
[4][IMG]
Files attached to this message
Filename Size Checksum (SHA256)
4 Elizabeth
Street - 53.3 063adfdc2eae422e2aba3f0b3feeb146f5ef3232f957cfbc2e97947ab0043f64
REDACTED MB
attachment.pdf
Waikanae
Chartered - 33.5 3e33c9aa5c7c9dc70c1febcd381bfc3378c4782135b756357fc4e54758ec58f5
REDACTED MB
attachment.pdf
Please click on the following link to download the attachments:
[5]https://files.kcdc.govt.nz/message/TMC7F...
This email or download link can not be forwarded to anyone else.
The attachments are available until: Wednesday, 9 February.
Message ID: TMC7Fv9ouNamrC0TvYMVP5
Files attached to this message
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Filename |Size| Checksum (SHA256) |
|--------------+----+----------------------------------------------------------------|
|Waikanae | | |
|Chartered - |33.5|3e33c9aa5c7c9dc70c1febcd381bfc3378c4782135b756357fc4e54758ec58f5|
|REDACTED | MB| |
|attachment.pdf| | |
|--------------+----+----------------------------------------------------------------|
|4 Elizabeth | | |
|Street - |53.3|063adfdc2eae422e2aba3f0b3feeb146f5ef3232f957cfbc2e97947ab0043f64|
|REDACTED | MB| |
|attachment.pdf| | |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Please click on the following link to download the attachments:
[6]https://files.kcdc.govt.nz/message/kRvnQ...
This email or download link can not be forwarded to anyone else.
The attachments are available until: Wednesday, 9 February.
Message ID: kRvnQA2YcshjnQUfrxjORq
The material in this email is confidential to the individual or entity
named above, and may be protected by legal privilege. If you are not the
intended recipient please do not copy, use or disclose any information
included in this communication without Kāpiti Coast District Council’s
prior permission.
References
Visible links
1. https://www.kapiticoast.govt.nz/our-dist...
2. https://covid19.govt.nz/
3. http://www.kapiticoast.govt.nz/
4. https://www.facebook.com/kapiticoastdist...
5. https://files.kcdc.govt.nz/message/TMC7F...
6. https://files.kcdc.govt.nz/message/kRvnQ...
Things to do with this request
- Add an annotation (to help the requester or others)
- Download a zip file of all correspondence