Cost:benefit of the PN cycle lanes
citizen made this Official Information request to Palmerston North City Council
The request was partially successful.
      From: citizen
      
    
    Dear Palmerston North City Council,
Please provide:
1. The originally projected number of daily users of the Pioneer Highway cycle lane and the confirmed number of users since its completion.
2. The total cost of the Pioneer Highway cycle lane, including consultation, planning, design and construction.
3. Please provide the number of events where cyclists have been harmed on Pioneer Highway in the 10 years prior to the project being initiated.
4. Please provide the number of PNCC staff or appointees who use the Pioneer Highway cycle lane that have been involved with approving the funding for it.
5. The total cost of all cycle lanes completed and proposed for Palmerston North city along with the total number of projected users, the total cost of benefits to the community and the projected total reduction in harm events per year as a result. Please reference all studies and activities conducted that produced these numbers, I do not require a copy of the actual studies or activities at this time.
6. The total amount of external funding (non-PNCC) that has been made available for any of the cycle lane projects.
7. Please provide details (personal identity redacted) of any declared conflict of interest by any PNCC staff member or appointee involved with approving any of the cycle lane projects or the funding for these.
8. Please provide the names of the companies or individuals who have been awarded contracts to complete any of the cycle lane consultation, planning, design and construction to date, and how much each has been awarded as payment.
9. Please provide any information other than public submissions, that relate to initiating, advancing or completing the cycle lanes projects that has been received by any PNCC personnel or appointees from, or sent to any entity or individual with an interest in any business that sells or markets bicycles, including any digital messages.
Yours faithfully,
A. Citizen
        Palmerston North City Council
      
    
    Thank you for your email. We will respond as soon as possible.
Please do not reply to this email as it is an auto generated response.
Customer Services
 Palmerston North City Council
 06 356 8199
        From: LGOIMA Requests
        Palmerston North City Council
      
    
    Kia ora A Citizen
 
We have received your official information request 
We received your request on 3/6/2024 seeking information on cycle.
 
We will do our best to respond to your request as soon as possible and no later than 2/7/2024. If we aren’t able to respond to your request within this 20 working day period, we will let you know.  
  
We are working on your request 
We are currently gathering any information we hold that relates to your request. If we need to clarify anything, we'll get in touch with you.  
  
On some occasions we need to charge for the cost of labour and materials involved in making information available, or for making information available urgently. If a charge is required, we will let you know before your request is processed.   
  
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us by emailing [email address]. Your reference number is LGOIMA SRC0148127  
  
Ngā mihi
 
Merle Lavin
Democracy & Governance Support Officer
Official Information Team
Legal Services 
Palmerston North City Council 
Te Marae o Hine − 32 The Square
Private Bag 11034, Palmerston North 4442
06 356 8199
pncc.govt.nz
show quoted sections
        From: LGOIMA Requests
        Palmerston North City Council
      
    
    Kia ora,
 
I refer to your official information request received on 3 June 2024 for
 various information on the Pioneer Highway cycleway and other cycleway
 projects.
 
Our response
Q1. The originally projected number of daily users of the Pioneer Highway
 cycle lane and the confirmed number of users since its completion.
Our Group Manager - Transport and Development advises that the original
 cycleway works were commenced in the 1990s and 2000s and this is not data
 that we hold. We have not undertaken a user count on this section. The
 shared pathway (used by both pedestrians, cyclists, mobility devices and
 wheeled recreational devices) that is currently being constructed in this
 area is not yet completed. Our Urban Cycle Network Masterplan will provide
 useful context on the development of cycleways in the city:
 [1]urban-cycle-network-masterplan-2019.pdf (pncc.govt.nz)
 
We are required under the Local Government Official Information and
 Meetings Act 1987 (LGOIMA) to provide you with a response to your request,
 given the information is not held by us we have decided to refuse your
 request under section 17(g) of the LGOIMA - the information sought does
 not exist.
 
Q2. The total cost of the Pioneer Highway cycle lane, including
 consultation, planning, design and construction.
The shared pathway that is currently being constructed in this area is not
 yet complete and as a result we are unable to provide total costs. As
 noted above the original Pioneer Highway cycleway dates back to the 1990s/
 2000s. Further information on what has been spent on cycleways throughout
 the city can be found under the Active Transport sections of our Annual
 Reports. These reports can be found online: [2]Long-term plan, annual
 budget and annual report | Palmerston North City Council (pncc.govt.nz)
 
Q3. Please provide the number of events where cyclists have been harmed on
 Pioneer Highway in the 10 years prior to the project being initiated.
Our Group Manager - Transport and Development advises the following, from
 2014 onwards, there has been one fatality, one serious casualty and
 fourteen minor casualties.
 
Q4. Please provide the number of PNCC staff or appointees who use the
 Pioneer Highway cycle lane that have been involved with approving the
 funding for it.
Council does not hold information on staff or consultant use of the cycle
 lanes in the city.
 
We are required under the LGOIMA to provide you with a response to your
 request, given we do not hold the information we have decided to refuse
 your request under section 17(g) of the LGOIMA - the information sought
 does not exist nor held by another agency.
 
Q5. The total cost of all cycle lanes completed and proposed for
 Palmerston North city along with the total number of projected users, the
 total cost of benefits to the community and the projected total reduction
 in harm events per year as a result. Please reference all studies and
 activities conducted that produced these numbers, I do not require a copy
 of the actual studies or activities at this time.
Given the scope of your request is for all cycle lanes completed and
 proposed in the city without a time period we have decided to refuse your
 request under section 17(f) of the LGOIMA - the information requested
 cannot be made available without substantial collation or research. We are
 happy to consider a request for specific project or reasonable time period
 if provided.
 
We note that many of the specific cycleway or shared pathway projects are
 set out on our website and reports to Council / relevant committees on
 these projects are available on our website: [3]Previous meetings, agendas
 and minutes | Palmerston North City Council (pncc.govt.nz)
 
The urban cycleways masterplan is available on our website:
 [4]urban-cycle-network-masterplan-2019.pdf (pncc.govt.nz)
 
As noted above, total costs per financial reporting period is available in
 our annual report for each year (search the document for the Active
 Transport sections): [5]Annual Report | Palmerston North City Council
 (pncc.govt.nz)
 
Q6. The total amount of external funding (non-PNCC) that has been made
 available for any of the cycle lane projects.
Given the scope of your request is for all cycle lanes completed and
 proposed in the city without a time period we have decided to refuse your
 request under section 17(f) of the LGOIMA - the information requested
 cannot be made available without substantial collation or research. We are
 happy to consider a request for specific project or reasonable time period
 if provided.
 
Q7. Please provide details (personal identity redacted) of any declared
 conflict of interest by any PNCC staff member or appointee involved with
 approving any of the cycle lane projects or the funding for these.
Our records show we do not hold any declarations of conflicts of interests
 for staff working on any cycle lane projects.  
 
In regard to appointed elected members, the pecuniary interests of our
 elected members is published pursuant to section 54A of the LGA 2022
 annually. This is available on our website (scroll to the bottom to see
 the previous two annual declarations): [6]Register of members’ pecuniary
 interests | Palmerston North City Council (pncc.govt.nz)   The Registers
 provide summaries of elected members’ financial, business and personal
 interests including certain assets, business associations and gifts they
 have received annually. The summaries are an individual snapshot of
 members’ interests annually.
In addition to the Register, elected members may make a declaration of any
 interest or conflicts during a meeting according to the requirements
 of Local Authorities (Members' Interests) Act 1968. These are recorded in
 the minutes of the meeting, which are available online: [7]Previous
 meetings, agendas and minutes | Palmerston North City Council
 (pncc.govt.nz).
Q8. Please provide the names of the companies or individuals who have been
 awarded contracts to complete any of the cycle lane consultation,
 planning, design and construction to date, and how much each has been
 awarded as payment.
We have decided to refuse your request under section 17(f) of the LGOIMA -
 the information requested cannot be made available without substantial
 collation or research. We are happy to consider a request for specific
 project or reasonable time period if provided such as the past two years.
 
Q9. Please provide any information other than public submissions, that
 relate to initiating, advancing or completing the cycle lanes projects
 that has been received by any PNCC personnel or appointees from, or sent
 to any entity or individual with an interest in any business that sells or
 markets bicycles, including any digital messages.
Given the scope of your request is for “the cycle lane projects” and “by
 any entity or individual”, this would require searching through our
 records for any communications from any bicycle companies in New Zealand
 or individual who sells/markets bikes. This would be difficult for us to
 narrow down and key word searches are unlikely to easily identify the
 communications you are seeking. We consider that a specific time period is
 unlikely to refine the request either. As a result we have decided to
 refuse your request under section 17(f) of the LGOIMA - the information
 requested cannot be made available without substantial collation or
 research.
 
 
You have the right to seek an investigation and review by the Ombudsman of
 this decision. Information about how to make a complaint is available at
 [8]www.ombudsman.parliament.nz or freephone 0800 802 602.
 
Ngā mihi,
 
 
Kate Scrase
 Legal Advisor
 Kaitohutohu ā-Ture
Official Information Team
 Legal Services
Palmerston North City Council
 [9][IMG] Te Marae o Hine − 32 The Square
 Private Bag 11034, Palmerston North 4442
06 356 8199
 [10]pncc.govt.nz
 
References
Visible links
 1. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/files/assets/pu...
 2. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/Council/Documen...
 3. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/Participate-Pal...
 4. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/files/assets/pu...
 5. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/Council/Documen...
 6. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/Council/Documen...
 7. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/Participate-Pal...
 8. http://www.ombudsman.parliament.nz/
 9. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/
 10. https://www.pncc.govt.nz/
Things to do with this request
- Add an annotation (to help the requester or others)
 - Download a zip file of all correspondence (note: this contains the same information already available above).
 

