Dear Ministry of Health,

With concern to Medsafe Covid 19 weekly safety report #10 listed here;

https://www.medsafe.govt.nz/COVID-19/saf...

It states that the deaths of two elderly patients have been entered into the CARM reporting system.

1) Would you provide redacted copies of the CARM report for those two cases which first removals all personally identifiable information from these reports.

2) Provide the reasoning CARM and Medsafe have determined the deaths not to be caused by the "administration of Comirnaty".

3) Provide a definition of what "administration" means with respect to (2).

4) Does the definition of "administration" include a restriction to a specific time frame, eg: from time from injection until 20 minutes after?

Yours faithfully,

Paul Jones

Dear OIA Requests,

Your response does not forefill our request in providing redacted data and we disagree with your statement that providing more data than that in the “line listings” puts privacy at risk.

We require further anonymized data to determine for ourselves if the Pfizer vaccine was responsible for the death, we don’t trust the governments judgement on the matter as clearly its lacking in judgement when it comes to counting the 26 Covid deaths such as in the instance of Eileen Margaret Hunter (link below) and the technicalities in language used to inflate covid death numbers by using PCR confirmed and symptomatic assumed cases.

https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/health/...

Laura Cleary of the Ministry of Health “cleary” disagrees with your assertion that more data puts patients privacy at risk as she released the comorbidity data for the 26 patient deaths under request H202007546, or in the following link;

https://fyi.org.nz/request/13913/respons...

As you would be aware in the USA they have the VAERS reporting system that provides many more case details whilst still being bound to not putting patients privacy at risk. We have provided you a printout in the following link of the level of detail given;

https://pdfhost.io/v/Hfi9sv.S0_VAERSEven...

So as originally request we require the redacted case data for the two patient deaths from Safety Report #10.

Yours sincerely,

Paul Jones