Building Consent Data
K Yang made this Official Information request to Statistics New Zealand
The request was successful.
      From: K Yang
      
    
    Dear Statistics New Zealand,
Could you please release the following data at territorial authority level? In terms of the length of the data, ideally it would be best if you can release the data from 2000 to 2020 if this is possible. In terms of the frequency of data, I would like to have yearly data if possible. Thank you very much. I am looking for the following three series.
1.The total land area of a residential house where a new building consent (not altered building consent but only new building consent) is issued in a territorial authority in a given year.
For example, if in 2000 Far North District issued two new building consents for residential houses listed as below.
1.1	The first new building consent is issued to a residential house with a land area of 100 sqm
1.2	The second new building consent is issued to a residential house with a land area of 150 sqm
The data I would like to have for Far North District in 2000 is 100+150=250 sqm
2.When a new building consent (not altered building consent but only new building consent) is issued, a residential house may or may not get built. I would like to have the number and floor area of residential houses that actually got built in a territorial authority in a given year.
3.Two of the following four series (3.1+3.2 or 3.3+3.4)
3.1	Average sale price of newly built residential houses per sqm in a territorial authority in a given year
3.2	Average sale price of newly built residential houses in a territorial authority in a given year
3.3	Average sale price of all residential houses (including new and existing stocks) per sqm in a territorial authority in a given year
3.4	Average sale price of all residential houses (including new and existing stocks) in a territorial authority in a given year
Thank you very much. I am looking for data related to a study of housing supply in New Zealand. Your contributions will be acknowledged when the study is published.
Yours faithfully,
K Yang
        From: Ewan Jonasen
        Statistics New Zealand
      
    
    Hello,
We are currently processing your request.
Stats NZ currently produces statistics on the number, floor area, and
 value of consents for dwellings. Please refer to
 [1]https://www.stats.govt.nz/topics/building
Total land area statistics, related to these consents (in reference to
 your first question), have not been produced before, although we may be
 able to produce an experimental series.
Due to the nature of the data it will have some limitations, and may take
 some time to produce.
If we are able to produce the data, the limitations may include (but are
 not limited to):
o Imperfect matching between street address descriptions recorded on the
 building consents data we receive and the parcel on which a dwelling
 will be built on.
 o In some cases, multiple homes may be built on the same piece of land.
 These homes may be built at different times, which can affect the
 accuracy of the results.
We do not currently hold any information on the final amount of new
 dwellings built within each Territorial Authority (question 2), or any
 sales that have occurred (question 3). We only collect data on building
 consents issued, some information on a sample of building projects, and
 information on property transfers, although these aren’t limited to just
 sales. Each Territorial Authority collects information on the issuance of
 Code Compliance Certificates which will be a better indicator of the
 amount of new dwellings built.
An experimental piece done previously has been used to provide insights
 into the proportion of dwelling consents that actually get built. This can
 be found here:
 [2]https://www.stats.govt.nz/experimental/e...
The estimated time it will take to produce these estimates will be around
 10 hours in total. The cost associated with this work will be $1,550 +
 gst.
Would you be able to notify us of the urgency of your request so that we
 may be able to set an appropriate deadline ?
If you are associated with a university, this work may be covered by the
 CONZUL Agreement. Please refer to
 [3]https://www.stats.govt.nz/services/custo...
Please contact me if you have any questions or would like to discuss your
 request in more detail.
 
Regards
Ewan Jonasen
 Customer Service Delivery – Customised Data
 Stats NZ | Tatauranga Aotearoa
BNZ Centre | 120 Hereford St, Christchurch 8011
[4]stats.govt.nz | +64 3 964 8720
 
About Aotearoa, for Aotearoa
Data that improves lives today and for generations to come
 
[5]Facebook | [6]Twitter | [7]LinkedIn
 
References
Visible links
 1. https://www.stats.govt.nz/topics/building
	https://www.stats.govt.nz/topics/building
 2. https://www.stats.govt.nz/experimental/e...
 3. https://www.stats.govt.nz/services/custo...
 4. http://www.stats.govt.nz/
 5. https://www.facebook.com/StatisticsNZ
 6. https://twitter.com/Stats_NZ
 7. https://www.linkedin.com/company/statist...
      From: K Yang
      
    
    Dear Ewan,
Thank you very much for your response and sorry for this late reply. I have been travelling in South Island so I only have limited time to deal with work-related stuff.
In your response, you mentioned the following:
“Total land area statistics, related to these consents (in reference to your first question), have not been produced before, although we may be able to produce an experimental series.”
My coauthor, Zhou, has contacted Donna MacColl, the librarian at the University of Auckland. The university has agreed to cover the cost associated with this research. Please produce the data.
You also mentioned the following:
“An experimental piece done previously has been used to provide insights
into the proportion of dwelling consents that actually get built. This can
be found here:
[2]https://www.stats.govt.nz/experimental/e...
The data cover the period from March 2001 to March 2017. Is it possible to update the data to cover the later period (e.g. up to March 2021 or Dec 2020)?
Lastly, you mentioned that you do not hold any information about any sales that have occurred (question 3). Do you know any sources/data where I can get the following information?
3.3	Average sale price of all residential houses (including new and existing stocks) per sqm in a territorial authority in a given year
3.4	Average sale price of all residential houses (including new and existing stocks) in a territorial authority in a given year
Thank you very much for your help. Your help and Stats NZ will be acknowledged if the study is published in a journal.
Yours sincerely,
K Yang
        From: Ewan Jonasen
        Statistics New Zealand
      
    
    Hello all
 
I am following up on this request with the data custodians, who will
 provide me with the amount of hours needed to complete the work. Once I
 have this, I will provide a quote with specifications.
 
As this is a data request, I will transfer and keep all correspondence and
 documentation within Stats NZ customer relationship management tool
 (Oneview), rather than OIA FYI.org.nz.
Data requests are covered by the Statistics Act. Please let me know if you
 have any concerns.
 
[1]https://fyi.org.nz/request/15289-buildin...
 
The Stats NZ reference number for this work is REQ-14322.
 
 
Regards
 
 
Ewan Jonasen
 Customer Service Delivery – Customised Data
 Stats NZ | Tatauranga Aotearoa
BNZ Centre | 120 Hereford St, Christchurch 8011
[2]stats.govt.nz | +64 3 964 8720
 
About Aotearoa, for Aotearoa
Data that improves lives today and for generations to come
 
[3]Facebook | [4]Twitter | [5]LinkedIn
 
 
From: Clare McGuigan <[email address]>
 Sent: Thursday, 10 June 2021 11:31 AM
 To: Donna MacColl <[email address]>
 Cc: Mingquan Zhou <[email address]>; Ewan Jonasen
 <[email address]>
 Subject: RE: CONZUL Agreement enquiry
 
Hi Donna,
Ewan will reply to you and Mingquan, with CONZUL hours in mind for using.
It may be the subject matter area who produce data (as we may not have
 access to all required).
I think he needs to follow up with Mingquan for more detail about the
 request.
 
Kind regards,
Clare
 
Clare McGuigan
Customer Service Delivery – Customised Data
 Stats NZ | Tatauranga Aotearoa
BNZ Centre | 120 Hereford St, Christchurch 8011
[6]stats.govt.nz | +64 3 964 8377
 
About Aotearoa, for Aotearoa
Data that improves lives today and for generations to come
 
[7]Facebook | [8]Twitter | [9]LinkedIn
 
 
 
From: Donna MacColl <[10][email address]>
 Sent: Thursday, 10 June 2021 7:53 AM
 To: Clare McGuigan <[11][email address]>
 Cc: Mingquan Zhou <[12][email address]>; Ewan Jonasen
 <[13][email address]>
 Subject: RE: CONZUL Agreement enquiry
 
Kia ora Clare and Ewan,
 
Mingquan would like to use CONZUL hours for a query she has sent through
 and Ewan has responded to. There is a little more detail in the link. If
 you need anymore information please get in touch.
 
Ngâ mihi,
Donna
 
Dr Donna MacColl - Research Services Adviser
Te Tumu Herenga | Libraries and Learning Services
Te Whare Wânanga o Tâmaki Makaurau | The University of Auckland
[14][email address] | Ph 64 9 923 7408
 
 
From: Mingquan Zhou <[15][email address]>
 Sent: Wednesday, 9 June 2021 9:40 pm
 To: Donna MacColl <[16][email address]>
 Subject: CONZUL Agreement enquiry
 
Hi Donna,
 
I am a PhD student in the Department of Accounting and Finance
 (ID:557485457). I’m working with another researcher (a PhD student in the
 Department of Property) on a project related to NZ housing supply, and we
 need some data from Stats NZ.
We’ve made an FOI request, and Stats NZ told us that the CONZUL Agreement
 might cover the fee if we are associated with uni.
Please refer to the link below for further information:
[17]https://fyi.org.nz/request/15289-buildin...
 
Could you please help us with it?
Thank you for your time!
 
Kind regards,
Mingquan
References
Visible links
 1. https://fyi.org.nz/request/15289-buildin...
 2. http://www.stats.govt.nz/
 3. https://www.facebook.com/StatisticsNZ
 4. https://twitter.com/Stats_NZ
 5. https://www.linkedin.com/company/statist...
 6. http://www.stats.govt.nz/
 7. https://www.facebook.com/StatisticsNZ
 8. https://twitter.com/Stats_NZ
 9. https://www.linkedin.com/company/statist...
 10. mailto:[email address]
 11. mailto:[email address]
 12. mailto:[email address]
 13. mailto:[email address]
 14. mailto:[email address]
 15. mailto:[email address]
 16. mailto:[email address]
 17. https://fyi.org.nz/request/15289-buildin...
        From: Ewan Jonasen
        Statistics New Zealand
      
    
    Hello all
 
The data custodian is having a look at the work involved for providing the
 two sets of information – I should now more later in the week.
Feel free to contact me if you have any questions or would like to know
 more.
 
Cheers
 
 
Ewan Jonasen
Design Analyst | Kaitâtari Hoahoa
Customer Service Delivery | Whakarato Ratonga Kiritaki
 Stats NZ | Tatauranga Aotearoa | [1]stats.govt.nz | +64 3 964 8720
 
About Aotearoa, for Aotearoa
Data that improves lives today and for generations to come
 
[2]Facebook | [3]Twitter | [4]LinkedIn
 
From: Ewan Jonasen
 Sent: Friday, 18 June 2021 10:00 AM
 To: Donna MacColl <[email address]>; K Yang
 <[FYI request #15289 email]>
 Cc: Mingquan Zhou <[email address]>; Clare McGuigan
 <[email address]>
 Subject: Stats NZ: CONZUL - OIA request for Building Consents Information
 
Hello all
 
I am following up on this request with the data custodians, who will
 provide me with the amount of hours needed to complete the work. Once I
 have this, I will provide a quote with specifications.
 
As this is a data request, I will transfer and keep all correspondence and
 documentation within Stats NZ customer relationship management tool
 (Oneview), rather than OIA FYI.org.nz.
Data requests are covered by the Statistics Act. Please let me know if you
 have any concerns.
 
[5]https://fyi.org.nz/request/15289-buildin...
 
The Stats NZ reference number for this work is REQ-14322.
 
 
Regards
 
 
Ewan Jonasen
 Customer Service Delivery – Customised Data
 Stats NZ | Tatauranga Aotearoa
BNZ Centre | 120 Hereford St, Christchurch 8011
[6]stats.govt.nz | +64 3 964 8720
 
About Aotearoa, for Aotearoa
Data that improves lives today and for generations to come
 
[7]Facebook | [8]Twitter | [9]LinkedIn
 
 
From: Clare McGuigan <[10][email address]>
 Sent: Thursday, 10 June 2021 11:31 AM
 To: Donna MacColl <[11][email address]>
 Cc: Mingquan Zhou <[12][email address]>; Ewan Jonasen
 <[13][email address]>
 Subject: RE: CONZUL Agreement enquiry
 
Hi Donna,
Ewan will reply to you and Mingquan, with CONZUL hours in mind for using.
It may be the subject matter area who produce data (as we may not have
 access to all required).
I think he needs to follow up with Mingquan for more detail about the
 request.
 
Kind regards,
Clare
 
Clare McGuigan
Customer Service Delivery – Customised Data
 Stats NZ | Tatauranga Aotearoa
BNZ Centre | 120 Hereford St, Christchurch 8011
[14]stats.govt.nz | +64 3 964 8377
 
About Aotearoa, for Aotearoa
Data that improves lives today and for generations to come
 
[15]Facebook | [16]Twitter | [17]LinkedIn
 
 
 
From: Donna MacColl <[18][email address]>
 Sent: Thursday, 10 June 2021 7:53 AM
 To: Clare McGuigan <[19][email address]>
 Cc: Mingquan Zhou <[20][email address]>; Ewan Jonasen
 <[21][email address]>
 Subject: RE: CONZUL Agreement enquiry
 
Kia ora Clare and Ewan,
 
Mingquan would like to use CONZUL hours for a query she has sent through
 and Ewan has responded to. There is a little more detail in the link. If
 you need anymore information please get in touch.
 
Ngâ mihi,
Donna
 
Dr Donna MacColl - Research Services Adviser
Te Tumu Herenga | Libraries and Learning Services
Te Whare Wânanga o Tâmaki Makaurau | The University of Auckland
[22][email address] | Ph 64 9 923 7408
 
 
From: Mingquan Zhou <[23][email address]>
 Sent: Wednesday, 9 June 2021 9:40 pm
 To: Donna MacColl <[24][email address]>
 Subject: CONZUL Agreement enquiry
 
Hi Donna,
 
I am a PhD student in the Department of Accounting and Finance
 (ID:557485457). I’m working with another researcher (a PhD student in the
 Department of Property) on a project related to NZ housing supply, and we
 need some data from Stats NZ.
We’ve made an FOI request, and Stats NZ told us that the CONZUL Agreement
 might cover the fee if we are associated with uni.
Please refer to the link below for further information:
[25]https://fyi.org.nz/request/15289-buildin...
 
Could you please help us with it?
Thank you for your time!
 
Kind regards,
Mingquan
References
Visible links
 1. http://www.stats.govt.nz/
 2. https://www.facebook.com/StatisticsNZ
 3. https://twitter.com/Stats_NZ
 4. https://www.linkedin.com/company/statist...
 5. https://fyi.org.nz/request/15289-buildin...
 6. http://www.stats.govt.nz/
 7. https://www.facebook.com/StatisticsNZ
 8. https://twitter.com/Stats_NZ
 9. https://www.linkedin.com/company/statist...
 10. mailto:[email address]
 11. mailto:[email address]
 12. mailto:[email address]
 13. mailto:[email address]
 14. http://www.stats.govt.nz/
 15. https://www.facebook.com/StatisticsNZ
 16. https://twitter.com/Stats_NZ
 17. https://www.linkedin.com/company/statist...
 18. mailto:[email address]
 19. mailto:[email address]
 20. mailto:[email address]
 21. mailto:[email address]
 22. mailto:[email address]
 23. mailto:[email address]
 24. mailto:[email address]
 25. https://fyi.org.nz/request/15289-buildin...
      From: K Yang
      
    
    Dear Ewan,
Thank you very much for your help. Please let us know when the data are released. Thanks!
Kind regards,
K Yang
      From: K Yang
      
    
    Dear Ewan,
Could you please give me an update? Thank you very much.
Yours sincerely,
K Yang
        From: Ewan Jonasen
        Statistics New Zealand
      
    
    Hello 
We are currently working on your job for Total Land Area Statistics of Consents - the analyst has nearly finished the work, however it will still need to be checked once completed. I don’t have a date yet for delivery. 
Unfortunately the experimental estimates can not be updated. After reviewing the work we found that the methodology doesn’t account for COVID-19. The lag and completion rate may have been impacted by COVID-19 or supply issues, which we need to understand. To update the data we would need to use a newer method that incorporates supplementary data. We would also need to understand the implications.
We suggest you focus on the broad finding of the experimental statistics - that roughly 97 percent of consented new dwellings usually get completed, and that there’s an average lag in the vicinity of nine months. 
Give me a ring and we can talk further. 
Regards
Ewan Jonasen 
Design Analyst | Kaitātari Hoahoa
Customer Service Delivery | Whakarato Ratonga Kiritaki
Stats NZ | Tatauranga Aotearoa | stats.govt.nz | +64 3 964 8720
About Aotearoa, for Aotearoa
Data that improves lives today and for generations to come
 
Facebook | Twitter | LinkedIn
show quoted sections
      From: K Yang
      
    
    Dear Ewan,
Thank you very much. We are looking forward to getting the data.
Thanks for helping us.
Yours sincerely,
K Yang
        From: Ewan Jonasen
        Statistics New Zealand
      
    
    Hello
 
Attached is the information you requested based on building consents
 issued and land area. Reference numbers for this work is REQ14322 and
 JOB11363
Please contact me if you have any questions.
 
Methodology to produce data:
 
Land area statistics are derived using building consents data and the LINZ
 Primary Parcel dataset. Building site addresses are supplied with the
 building consents data, and this is used to get a match to the PP dataset.
 Only matched consents are included in the analysis.
Some consents are subsequently removed using a set of criteria. This
 includes:
o Portable housing: often produced at a location but then moved to its
 permanent site later, so the site address has a high probability of
 being incorrect.
 o No retirement village units are to be included. Included are
 stand-alone houses, apartments, and townhouses/flats/units. Two
 categories of dwellings were created for the datasets: (1) stand-alone
 houses, and (2) apartments, townhouses, flats, units, and other
 dwellings.
o Retirement village units were not included for a couple of
 reasons, but primarily because:
+ They are often on land where a large portion is occupied by
 other dwelling types
 + They are not open for consumption for the majority of people
o Outlier cases where the total land area for a set of consents do not
 make sense. This usually involves filtering out cases where the land
 is likely to be too small. Examples include cases where multiple
 consents may have been linked incorrectly to the same address (and
 thus parcel).
The limitations of this includes:
o The matching cannot be guaranteed to be 100% correct
 o Not all consents are matched to a parcel
 o In some cases multiple parcels may be under the same title
 o It does not include information on any existing buildings on the
 parcel (that hasn’t had a consent since April 1990)
 o For a single dwelling, we cannot guarantee that the land use is
 isolated to that particular dwelling:
o Other buildings may be on the same site (those which were
 consented before April 1990)
 o Other dwellings use more/less of the land
 o Dwellings may have been built and demolished
 o We may have some cases of incomplete data where councils have
 accidentally not provided us with all of their data
 o A small proportion of our dwellings are for conversions. This is
 where a non-residential building, for example, has been converted
 into dwellings. This can be hotels, garages etc. We aren’t able
 to isolate any mixed-use for these consents either
o Quality of estimates are not guaranteed to be the same between areas
 (TA/Region) or building type:
o Better matching rates
 o Better quality data
On an individual dwelling-by-dwelling basis there is no way to determine
 what the actual land use will be. This means that there may be some issues
 with directly comparing TA’s that don’t have equal proportions of
 rural/urban areas. As a result, one of the datasets contains data grouped
 according to the Functional urban areas classification. More information
 on this classification is available on our website. I’ve also added in a
 column that contains the estimated median land area allocated to each
 dwelling within a particular group. The land are allocated to each
 dwelling is done in a very simple manner:
 1. For each parcel, find all dwellings consents on it.
  2. Split the total land area for each parcel by the number of dwellings
 on it.
  3. Derive statistics based on these values.
This means that (a) we assume all dwellings on a parcel get an equal share
 of the land, and (b) the statistics for any year is based on all dwellings
 consented, even if they were consented in a later year. This ensures we
 don’t double count land.
 
A lot of this does not actually present any conceptual issues, and this is
 particularly true for stand-alone houses since they are the simplest cases
 to deal with.
 
In terms of land-use again, parcels occupied with high-density dwellings
 may not be completely comparable in some cases to dwellings such as
 stand-alone houses. This is because many apartments, although built on
 some piece of land, may not actually allow people to use any of the land
 itself (ie there’s no outdoors space).
 
 
Descriptions for selected variables:
File 1: ‘Land-area-statistics-TA-Year-Type.csv’
o Total_dwellings: the number of new dwellings consented of that type in
 the given area and year. This includes dwellings filtered out.
 o Dwellings_included: for various reasons, including those mentioned
 earlier, the matching is not perfect, and some subsequently get
 removed as part of the data-cleaning step. This variable reflects the
 total number of dwellings (by type, area, and year) that we included.
 o Total_land_area_of_dwellings_included: The dwellings included were
 used to produce a total – this total reflects the total amount of land
 area allocated to the dwellings of that type and in the area and year
 involved.
File 2: ‘Land-area-statistics-TA-Year-Type-FUA.csv’
o Median_land_area_per_dwelling: As before, a subset of dwellings were
 used (by type, year, area) to produce a weighted median of the land
 area allocated to each dwelling – This provides a ballpark measure of
 the amount of land available per dwellings, regardless of how it is
 actually used.
 o Functional_urban_areas:
 [1]https://www.stats.govt.nz/methods/functi....
 
 
Final notes
o Due to the experimental nature of these statistics, we cannot
 guarantee is at our usual publication quality and that it should be
 used with caution.
 o We estimate that most (~95%+) of new dwellings consented are
 eventually built (although this can fluctuate and dip below this),
 although we have to recognise that some will get cancelled.
 
 
If you would like to get in contact with me to discuss things further I
 would be more than happy to.
 
 
 
Regards
 
 
Ewan Jonasen
Design Analyst | Kaitātari Hoahoa
Customer Service Delivery | Whakarato Ratonga Kiritaki
 Stats NZ | Tatauranga Aotearoa | [2]stats.govt.nz | +64 3 964 8720
 
About Aotearoa, for Aotearoa
Data that improves lives today and for generations to come
 
[3]Facebook | [4]Twitter | [5]LinkedIn
 
References
Visible links
 1. https://www.stats.govt.nz/methods/functi...
 2. http://www.stats.govt.nz/
 3. https://www.facebook.com/StatisticsNZ
 4. https://twitter.com/Stats_NZ
 5. https://www.linkedin.com/company/statist...
Things to do with this request
- Add an annotation (to help the requester or others)
 - Download a zip file of all correspondence (note: this contains the same information already available above).
 

