Clarifications Regarding the Consistency of Decisions by INZ on SMC Resident Applications
Vipin made this Official Information request to Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment
The request was refused by Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment.
      From: Vipin
      
    
    Dear Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment,
Kindly help me with precise and accurate answer to all these queries
My following queries (1) - (8) are regarding the SMC Resident Visa applications based on same job role/offer as Customer Care Representative in 2Degrees Mobile Limited and applied from Christchurch Location and applied against the same ANZSCO code 313112 ICT Customer Support Officer during the time frame Jun 2016 - Till Now.
(1)How many of the applications got approved by INZ?
(2)How many applications got declined with the reason- INZ is not satisfied that the Applicant’s Employment is a not a substantial match for the Claimed ANZSCO Code 313112(ICT Customer Support Officer)?
(3) Did INZ arrive at contradictory decisions on these SMC Resident Visa Applications?or Does INZ being inconsistent on the decisions for these applications?
To clarify more in above Question (3)- Does INZ declined Residents Visa applications with the reason -INZ was not satisfied that the Applicant’s Employment is a substantial match for the Claimed ANZSCO Code 313112(ICT Customer Support Officer? (Points claimed for the Skilled Employment/Offer was not awarded)
and 
Some Resident visa's approved and INZ was satisfied that the Applicant's employment is a substantial match with the Claimed ANZSCO Code 313112? (Points claimed for the Skilled Employment/Offer was awarded)
Please consider only the applications which are declined with the above-stated as the main reason.
(4)If the Answer to the Question number (3) is yes, what are the circumstances which led INZ to make those contradictory decisions? Please state the Immigration Law/Rule which gives privilege to INZ for taking that kind of contradictory decisions.
(5) When considering only the declined Visa applications in the Question (3), Does the same Visa/immigration Officer declined all the applications?
(6)If the Answer the Question (5) is yes, did that Immigration officer followed the Standards of Integrity and Conduct, a code of conduct issued by the State Services Commissioner under State Sector Act 1988, Section 57?
(7)Again If the Answer to the Question (5) is yes, Did INZ got any formal complaints against that Visa/Immigration officer? If Yes how many complaints received and from how many applicants?
(8) Again, If the Answer to the Question (5) is yes Did INZ take any formal disciplinary actions against that Immigration officer like Issue formal warning, Termination from the job, Quality training etc. till now? If yes what action was taken and what was the reason for the disciplinary action?
Yours faithfully,
Vipin
        From: *OIA
        Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment
      
    
     
Ref: 1718-0407
 
Dear Vipin
On behalf of the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment I
 acknowledge your email of 25 September 2017 requesting under the Official
 Information Act 1982 (the Act), the following:
My following queries (1) - (8) are regarding the SMC Resident Visa
 applications based on same job role/offer as Customer Care Representative
 in 2Degrees Mobile Limited and applied from Christchurch Location and
 applied against the same ANZSCO code 313112 ICT Customer Support Officer
 during the time frame Jun 2016 - Till Now.
 
(1)How many of the applications got approved by INZ?
 
(2)How many applications got declined with the reason- INZ is not
 satisfied that the Applicant’s Employment is a not a substantial match for
 the Claimed ANZSCO Code 313112(ICT Customer Support Officer)?
 
(3) Did INZ arrive at contradictory decisions on these SMC Resident Visa
 Applications?or Does INZ being inconsistent on the decisions for these
 applications?
 
To clarify more in above Question (3)- Does INZ declined Residents Visa
 applications with the reason -INZ was not satisfied that the Applicant’s
 Employment is a substantial match for the Claimed ANZSCO Code 313112(ICT
 Customer Support Officer? (Points claimed for the Skilled Employment/Offer
 was not awarded) and Some Resident visa's approved and INZ was satisfied
 that the Applicant's employment is a substantial match with the Claimed
 ANZSCO Code 313112? (Points claimed for the Skilled Employment/Offer was
 awarded) Please consider only the applications which are declined with the
 above-stated as the main reason.
 
(4)If the Answer to the Question number (3) is yes, what are the
 circumstances which led INZ to make those contradictory decisions? Please
 state the Immigration Law/Rule which gives privilege to INZ for taking
 that kind of contradictory decisions.
 
(5) When considering only the declined Visa applications in the Question
 (3), Does the same Visa/immigration Officer declined all the applications?
 
(6)If the Answer the Question (5) is yes, did that Immigration officer
 followed the Standards of Integrity and Conduct, a code of conduct issued
 by the State Services Commissioner under State Sector Act 1988, Section
 57?
 
(7)Again If the Answer to the Question (5) is yes, Did INZ got any formal
 complaints against that Visa/Immigration officer? If Yes how many
 complaints received and from how many applicants?
 
(8) Again, If the Answer to the Question (5) is yes Did INZ take any
 formal disciplinary actions against that Immigration officer like Issue
 formal warning, Termination from the job, Quality training etc. till now?
 If yes what action was taken and what was the reason for the disciplinary
 action?
 
Your request is being processed in accordance with the Act and a response
 will be sent to you in due course. If you have any enquiries regarding
 your request feel free to contact us via email [MBIE request email] or using
 the contact details below.
 
Yours sincerely,
Alan Witcombe
MANAGER, MINISTERIAL SERVICES
Corporate, Governance and Information
Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment
Level 4, 15 Stout Street, PO Box 1473, Wellington 6140
 
[1]www.govt.nz - your guide to finding and using New Zealand government
 services
show quoted sections
References
Visible links
 1. http://www.govt.nz/
        From: Cat Beach
        Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment
      
    
    Dear Vipin,
 
I am writing in regards to your request under the Official Information Act
 1982 received 25 September 2017.
 
Please find attached our response to your request.
 
Kind regards
 
Catherine Beach
SENIOR BUSINESS ADVISOR
 
Operations Support - Visa Services, Immigration New Zealand
 Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment
 
[1][email address]  
Level 1, 15 Stout Street, PO Box 1473, Wellington, New Zealand
 
 
 
 
[2]www.govt.nz - your guide to finding and using New Zealand government
 services
show quoted sections
References
Visible links
 1. mailto:[email address]
 2. http://www.govt.nz/
Things to do with this request
- Add an annotation (to help the requester or others)
 - Download a zip file of all correspondence (note: this contains the same information already available above).
 

