Official Information Act request
Lee M. made this Official Information request to Privacy Commissioner
The request was refused by Privacy Commissioner.
From: Lee M.
Dear Privacy Commissioner
At your website link https://www.privacy.org.nz/the-privacy-a... there is an explanation of "Exemptions from the (Privacy) Act" in which it is stated;
"Only a few organisations and people are not 'agencies'. Other rules exist to govern how they manage personal information, so the Privacy Act does not cover what they do. Organisations that aren't covered by the Privacy Act include: (inter alia) --- courts and tribunals, in relation to their judicial functions".
I would appreciate you providing me with the following information under the Official Information Act:
1. Please provide me with copies of the "other rules" that you referred to in the abovementioned quotation and that apparently exist to govern how reviewers - contracted by Fairway Resolution Limited under a dispute resolution services agreement entered into between the ACC and Fairway Resolution Limited in relation to certain obligations that the ACC has under the AC Act - manage personal information that they collect, source, share, use, disclose and store in the course of fulfilling their duties, responsibilities and functions under Part 5 of the AC Act. This particular request takes into consideration your Case Note 232848 [2012] NZ PrivCmr 3 which commented as follows: "Outside the appeal process it is each independent reviewer, rather than DRSL (now Fairway Resolution Limited), who is the custodian of the records of each review hearing."
2. What legislation, regulations, policies, or guidelines - if any - exist to govern how reviewers - as described above - manage personal information as described above? And please provide me with copies of same or direct me to where I can readily access this information.
3. You have determined that a reviewer is not "an agency" for the purposes of the Privacy Act 1993. One of two reasons given by you for this is that a reviewer seeking information on a matter is - for the purposes of the Privacy Act 1993 - a "tribunal acting in relation to its judicial functions". Please provide me with a copy of your aforementioned determination as well as copies of all information that your office and management and staff hold in relation thereto, and how and when it was reached. This includes, but is not limited to, all hard-copy, electronic and 'stored in the head' information. Please also provide me with copies of all information sought and received from any external sources, including the ACC and Fairway Resolution Limited, in relation to this matter and request.
4. Reviewers act "in the nature of a tribunal". Neither they nor Fairway Resolution Limited are a statutorily established "court or tribunal". If your determination that a reviewer is not "an agency" for the purposes of the Privacy Act 1993 has been tested in a court of law in New Zealand, please provide me with copies of all information that your office and management and staff hold in relation to such a case or cases. This includes, but is not limited to, all hard-copy, electronic and 'stored in the head' information. Please also provide me with copies of all information sought and received from any external sources, including the ACC and Fairway Resolution Limited, in relation to this matter and request.
5. Privacy Commissioner complainants who are ACC claimants and who have applications for review yet to be heard, or who have applications for review that have already been heard, by Fairway Resolution Limited are routinely being advised, albeit in a somewhat unclear and implied fashion, by your management and staff that their complaints cannot be investigated because Fairway Resolution Limited - the organisation - is (also) not "an agency" for the purposes of the Privacy Act 1993. This seems to be an extension or addition to the determination by you that "reviewers" are not "an agency" for the purposes of the Privacy Act 1993.. Please provide me with a copy of the determination by your office that supports the aforementioned advice, views and opinions of your management and staff .. Please also provide me with copies of all information that your office and management and staff hold in relation to the aforementioned determination, how and when it was reached. This includes, but is not limited to, all hard-copy, electronic and 'stored in the head' information. In addition, please provide me with copies of all information sought and received from any external sources, including the ACC and Fairway Resolution Limited, in relation to this matter and request.
If any part of this request is not clear, please let me know and I will attempt to clarify as best as I am able.
Yours faithfully
Lee M.
From: Privacy No Reply
Privacy Commissioner
Thank you for your email. We are assessing your enquiry, and will contact
you within three working days.
Please do not reply to this email as it is not monitored – direct replies
to [1][Privacy Commissioner request email]
If you would like to visit our [2]website or our [3]FAQs in the meantime,
please feel free to do so.
Kind regards,
Enquiries Team
Office of the Privacy Commissioner Te Mana Matapono Matatapu
PO Box 10094, The Terrace, Wellington 6143
Level 13, 51-53 Shortland Street, Auckland 1010
T 0800 803 909
E [4][Privacy Commissioner request email]
privacy.org.nz
Privacy is about protecting personal information, yours and others’. To
find out how, and to stay informed, [5]subscribe to our newsletter
or follow us online
[6]cid:image001.png@01D12CDF.9C301120 [7]cid:image002.png@01D12CDF.9C301120
Caution: If you have received this message in error please notify the
sender immediately and delete this message along with any attachments.
Please treat the contents of this message as private and confidential.
Thank you.
References
Visible links
1. mailto:[Privacy Commissioner request email]
2. http://www.privacy.org.nz/
3. https://www.privacy.org.nz/your-privacy/...
4. mailto:[Privacy Commissioner request email]
5. http://privacy.org.nz/subscribe/
6. http://www.facebook.com/PrivacyNZ
7. https://twitter.com/NZPrivacy
From: Jane Foster
Privacy Commissioner
Jane Foster
General Counsel
Office of the Privacy Commissioner Te Mana Matapono Matatapu
PO Box 10094, The Terrace, Wellington 6143
Level 8, 109 Featherston Street, Wellington, New Zealand
T +64 4 494 7140 DDI
E [email address]
privacy.org.nz
Privacy is about protecting personal information, yours and others'. To find out how, and to stay informed, subscribe to our newsletter or follow us online.
Caution: If you have received this message in error please notify the sender immediately and delete this message along with any attachments. Please treat the contents of this message as private and confidential. Thank you.
Lee M. left an annotation ()
The reason for the refusal to provide me with the requested Official Information does not comply with the OIA. I will now complain to the Ombudsman, however, there is no doubt that the Ombudsman will not find the Privacy Commissioner at fault in any way. Ultimately I will be taking this matter, and numerous other similar failings by the Privacy Commissioner to comply with the Privacy Act, to the HRRT.
Things to do with this request
- Add an annotation (to help the requester or others)
- Download a zip file of all correspondence
Lee M. left an annotation ()
Was advised on 12 April 2016; "We are assessing your enquiry, and will contact you within three working days." It is now 5 working days later and nothing further from the Privacy Commissioner's office.
Link to this