PRINCIPLES AND FUNCTIONS
INFORMATION STRATEGY
INFORMATION PRACTICE
INFORMATION MANAGEMENT
Ensuring SSC has al the information it requires to meet its
Managing our information in accordance with our
needs, by identifying, col ection and storing data
principles, best practices and obligations
SHIFTS
SHIFTS
•
Infrastructure - SSC developed standardised systems (both
•
Stewardship – Strategic information is managed as an
technological and human processes)
asset an stewarded through our information
•
Map – good understanding al our strategic information assets
management practices
•
Commissioning – SSC makes good information investments
•
Role - clarity of what information SSC holds on behalf
•
Integration – where practicable our information assets
of the system
are integrated
SUCCESS
SUCCESS
•
Maturity - SSC builds its information management
•
Future proofed - SSC builds our systems in
practices to support both our external
a co-ordinated way with one eye to our future
obligations, and our internal business
•
Errors – reduce errors through good data
requirements in the most efficient and
management practices
effective way.
•
Cost effective – System needs are met
within our resource constraints
INFORMATION INTO
INSIGHT
Information supports SSC to monitor,
design and evaluate the performance of
the State Sector
SHIFTS
SHIFTS
•
Capability - SSC understands and builds the
•
Flow- we understand who the customer(s) is/are
capability to analyse our information
for all our information
•
Research programme - a research and evaluation
•
Visualisation – information is presented in a way that
programme is established and maintained to analyse
makes it useable and easily understood for our
critical system risks and opportunities
customers
SUCCESS
SUCCESS
•
Insights - our information is used to derive insights on
•
Sharing – our information is open, unless withheld due
how to improve performance of the system, agencies
to privacy and security.
and chief executives or any form of customer
segmentation
Understanding who needs our information both
internal y and external y and sharing it with them
Using our Information to draw actionable insight
INFORMATION SHARING
INFORMATION ANALYTICS
2015
SSC INFORMATION ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
ROLE
DESCRIPTION
KEY RESPONSIBILITIES
SENIOR DATA
A role held by a tier-2 manager sitting on SMT (currently the EMPG CE) who • Manages risks around high value public information releases
STEWARD
has oversight over information management and release across SSC on • Reviews information management and release policies
behalf of the Commissioner.
• Reviews and sponsors new strategic information projects
• Communicate and promote the value of information
SMT
SMT are the Governance group who uphold the principles of the Information • Approves SSC’s information management and release policies
Strategy in relation to decisions around managing SSC’s strategic • Makes investment decisions around improving our information resources, including commissioning work through col aboration hub processes
information.
• Approval over what is ‘Strategic’ information (and therefore subject to al controls)
DATA OWNER
Has legal rights over the information, including copyright ownership. For SSC, • Provides permission for the use and reuse of their information, either through written consent, or the use of creative common licences or similar copyright
as a department, al information developed internal y or acquired via
legislative provision, are owned by the Crown. Information supplied by
holders of external copyright remains in their ownership regardless of the
usage licence acquired by SSC. Ownership of an information system does not
equate to ownership of the information.
DATA STEWARD
Stewardship duties belong to business units within SSC that are most • Adheres to the information management and release policies
concerned with a particular information resource. This is a business • Establishes information requirements and supports procurement of information resources.
function, not a technical one.
• Sets expectations for how information is to be managed, including security, privacy and access settings
• Ensures information is used in accordance with the purposes for which it was col ected, including adherence to copyright
• Approval and contribution to open data releases
DATA CUSTODIAN
The technical specialists who develop and administer information • Develops and administers the Information Strategy and information and release policies
management practices. The Strategic Information Team is general y the • Advises on, and monitors the use of, SSC’s information management and release policies
custodian on behalf of SSC, although external service providers managed via
contract (e.g. TMIS) can also be the data custodian.
• Sources data and metadata, in terms of content, quality, and conformance with standards and the Public Records Act, 2005
• Ensures that appropriate Service Level Agreements are in place with platform and data services support providers, including CASS IT
• Ensures expectations and rules set by the Data Steward are appropriately implemented
• Co–ordinates release of data to agencies to drive performance improvement and the public under open data requirements.
• Supports information creation through day-to-day service provision and maintenance of information systems
• Support SMT in its role, in particular in assessment of investment in strategic information
SSC DATA USER
SSC staff who analyse information, as part of their day-to-day work, to • Knows their responsibilities with information as set out in SSC’s information protocols
generate actionable insights.
• Must adhere to the privacy and security rules and guidance set out in SSC’s information protocols, in particular when external y releasing information
• Must adhere to copyright obligations
EXTERNAL DATA
Those looking to SSC information to provide them insights into the State • Must adhere to Crown copyright obligations
USER
Sector.
SSC Strategic Information
SSC INFORMATION
MANAGEMENT PROTOCOLS
PROTOCOLS
PRACTICES
RESOURCES
•
Information is an important asset with appropriate governance structures
•
INFORMATION ROLES AND
WE EMBED OUR INFORMATION
RESPONSIBILITIES
ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES
•
Information sources each have a steward responsible for life-cycle management
•
All staff know their responsibilities with information
•
These responsibilities also apply to external researchers given access to SSC data
•
Legal and ethical obligations around managing information are adhered to
•
PRIVACY POLICY
WE SECURE THE CONFIDENTIALITY
•
CONFIDENTIALITY GUIDELINES
AND PRIVACY OF OUR
•
The permissions we have to use data are understood
INFORMATION
•
Security practices are built into our processes and infrastructure
•
Privacy or security breaches are managed openly and quickly, recognising the seriousness of
maintaining confidentiality
•
All data that is collected has a clear use and its value is understood
•
INFORMATION REGISTER
WE INVEST WISELY IN OUR
•
COLLECTION GUIDELINES
INFORMATION RESOURCE
•
Information is actively used, and then archived, to get full value from it
•
Data is appropriately and efficiently sourced
•
Information infrastructure is invested in to enhance the value of our data
•
There is a culture of professionalism and good practice
WE ASSURE OUR INFORMATION
QUALITY
•
Information meets the needs of users, within available resources
•
Information is accurate
•
Information is timely enough to be of value to users
•
Information is consistent
•
Methods used to produce information are understood and documented
•
Common information standards are used to manage SSC information
•
INFORMATION REGISTER
WE SHARE AN INFORMATION
LANGUAGE
•
SSC uses national and international information standards where possible
•
SSC promotes common information standards across the system
• Information infrastructure assists with turning data into insight
• RELEASE GUIDELINES
WE USE OUR INFORMATION
WISELY
• Processes get the right information to the right people at the right time
• DECLARATION ON OPEN AND
• Published information is presented clearly and supported by analysis
TRANSPARENT GOVERNMENT
• Published information is open and accessible
• Published information is understandable
• Significant errors in published information are corrected quickly
link to page 4
State Services Commission (SSC)
Information Management Protocols
__________________________________________________
A principal of SSC’s
Information Strategy is to manage our strategic information
1 in
accordance with our principles, best practices and obligations.
The six information protocols are:
1.
We embed our information roles and responsibilities
2.
We protect the confidentiality, privacy and security of our information
3.
We invest wisely in our information resources
4.
We assure our information quality
5.
We share an information language
6.
We use our information wisely
Each protocol consists of:
•
Practices: short statements to be used by SCC teams to guide behaviour around
information.
•
Resources: links to more in-depth material to support SSC teams.
The information protocols draw, where appropriate, on Statistics New Zealand’s
Principles
and Protocols for Producers of Tier 1 Statistics which can be found at
http://www.statisphere.govt.nz.
1 Strategic information is defined in th
e Information Management and Release Policy document.
2208917_6.docx
PROTOCOL 1: We embed our information roles and responsibilities
1.1 Our information is an important asset with appropriate governance structures
SMT have governing authority over SSC’s strategic information. Key governance
responsibilities include making key investment decisions and establishing the
information management practices. SMT are supported by the Strategic Information
team (SIT).
RESOURCE:
Information Roles and Responsibilities
1.2 Information sources each have a steward responsible for life-cycle management
All data coming into SSC has a business owner, called the Data Steward. The Data
Steward is ultimately responsible that the data is well managed.
The Data Steward is supported by Data Custodians. These are technical data
specialists who develop and administer data management practices. Data Custodians
will generally be SIT, but may be CASS IT or contracted out to external provider.
All data has a data owner that ultimately has legal rights over the information. For
information, where SSC is the data owner, either information that is developed
internally or acquired via legislative provision, these assets are in owned by the Crown.
RESOURCE:
Information Roles and Responsibilities
1.3
All staff know their responsibilities with our information
These protocols set out the roles, responsibilities and rules for SSC staff to adhere to.
All staff involved in the use of SSC strategic information are aware of their obligation to
protect confidentiality and privacy, and are aware of the penalties for wrongful
disclosure.
1.4 These responsibilities also apply to external researchers given access to SSC data
Bona fide researchers may be given access to anonymised individual-level SSC data
to undertake statistical work that is in the public interest and subject to their ethics
application. A condition of granting access is that researchers agree to follow the
SSC’s information management and release practices as if they were an SSC
employee. A CASS approved method must be used to exchange unit record data.
A Privacy Impact Assessment should be undertaken for all major requests that involve
sharing individual-level SSC data on a systematic basis with new strategic or research
partner(s).
2208917_6.docx
PROTOCOL 2: We secure the confidentiality and privacy of our information
2.1 Legal and ethical obligations around managing information are adhered to
The legislative and ethical obligations governing the collection, storage and release of
information are built into SSC policies and information practices (SSC’s Privacy Officer
is responsible for ensuring SSC policies and practices conform to legislative
obligations).
All staff involved in the use of SSC strategic information are aware of these obligations
to protect confidentiality and privacy and the penalties for wrongful disclosure, and
adhere to these obligations.
RESOURCE:
Privacy Policy
2.2 The permissions we have to use data are understood
Survey respondents and data owners provide permissions for the use of their data.
SSC only uses data in a way consistent with these permissions and the reason(s) for
which the information is collected. Permissions and use of information is documented
and stored with our information asset register. Staff need to confirm that they
understand and agree to these permissions prior to getting access to some types of
strategic information.
We are sure of the need for the data before asking for it. Respondents are informed of
their rights and obligations in providing information. Respondents are clear why we are
collecting the information and are aware of our security controls to maintain their
privacy and confidentiality. The respondent’s confidentiality is always strictly preserved
unless they have explicitly agreed to the contrary.
2.3 Security Practices are built into our processes and infrastructure
Security practices are built into our infrastructure. SIT and CASS IT administer security
practices across our business intelligence (BI) environment. Identifying information
(such as name) should be removed from BI datasets or datasets provided to external
researchers. Rules are established (such as minimum counts) to ensure identifying
information is suppressed before aggregated results are released outside SSC. SIT
can help with establishing, and checking the implementation, of these rules.
Security practices include explicitly setting out the rules for access to private and
confidential information by a user. It is the data steward, who sets those rules, which
must be documented. The data steward also needs to ensure users acknowledge the
rules that they can operate within, including their responsibilities to maintain privacy
and confidentiality, including keeping an audit trail.
2.4 Privacy or security breaches are managed openly and quickly, recognising the
seriousness of maintaining confidentiality
As per our Privacy Policy, the Privacy Officer is notified immediately of any potential
privacy breaches.
2208917_6.docx
PROTOCOL 3: We invest wisely in our information resources
3.1 Strategic Information is invested in to enhance the value of our data
When assessing whether to invest in a new information collection, we must first
consider if it meets the definition of strategic information.
If the new collection does meet the criteria, SSC teams should talk to SIT who can
help assess whether to invest in the information and the level of maturity based on a
number of technical consideration that include value for money.
RESOURCE:
Collections Guidelines
3.2 All data that is collected has a clear use and its value is understood
The value of the data we collect is understood. Data collection has clear objectives
and information needs that we are attempting to address. We balance the need to
collect data to inform decision making against the costs of production and the burden
placed on the system.
Investment decisions are made by the SMT. Work programmes are periodically
reviewed to ensure their relevance, and justify their continuation.
3.3 Information is actively used, and then archived, to get full value from it
We maximise the use and value of existing data by integrating or aligning it with
administrative sources. SSC understands (through the Data Architecture) and has
shared access to all our information resources to be able to get best value from the
information. We share our information with the system and public so that they can
derive value from it.
Business processes adhere to the CASS disposal and retention policies and rules set
out in the Public Records Act 2005. In practice however, most data is retained
indefinitely due to its potential research value, subject to security, confidentiality and
statutory obligations.
3.4 Data is appropriately and efficiently sourced
We ask for data only once and then share internally. Similarly, Information requests to
the same respondents are co-ordinated, in particular to agencies and CE’s.
Existing data sources are used wherever possible and existing collection mechanisms
are considered when looking to capture new data. Appropriate opportunities to reduce
costs are actively sought. These include economies of scale, data integration, and
methodologies and systems that use generic and/or automated processes
Data collection is designed in a supplier friendly way and with sufficient flexibility to
accommodate changes in user needs. SIT can help develop and build standards for
data collection, including the design of survey questionnaires.
3.5 Information infrastructure is invested in to enhance the value of our data
SSC’s existing information infrastructure, referred to as the BI environment, is the
enterprise solution for SSC. Where possible SSC uses this BI environment to enable
better integration of data. When investing in new data collection, storage or
administrative systems SSC assesses it for compatibility with the existing BI
environment.
New technologies are routinely investigated to see if they would provide
value to the BI environment. Where possible SSC look to link the BI
2208917_6.docx
environment with other central agency partners for a whole of CASS enterprise
solution.
PROTOCOL 4: We assure our information quality
4.1 There is a culture of professionalism and good practice
Analysts act with integrity, objectivity and comply with SSC’s information protocols.
SSC uses good data and project management processes in the production of
information. SSC invests in training and development to ensure analysts have the
information skills required. SSC regularly assesses information processes and tools;
seeking opportunities to implement new technologies and maintaining a culture of peer
review.
4.2 Information meets the needs of users, within available resources
SSC designs new information to be relevant to users’ needs, within available financial
resources. SSC teams understand who the key users of their existing information are
and why they use it. They consult their key users before making substantial changes to
how the information is collected, managed or reported.
4.3 Information is accurate
SSC produces its information using sound data and methods. It does this by validating
incoming data, and understanding or, where possible, controlling the level of error in its
information (e.g. minimum counts).
Reports that will be published or ministerial briefings must have any quantitative
information checked by SIT, or someone with the requisite knowledge.
4.4 Information is timely enough to be of value to users
To be relevant, information needs to be released in sufficient time to meet key users’
needs. Timeliness is a decision involving trade-offs between quality and cost.
Regular publicly released information should have planned release dates.
4.5
Information is consistent
Key information results should be reported consistently (i.e. there is one version of the
truth). Analysts should check to see whether information has already been reported,
and if so, use the same figure. Where information is not comparable, it should be
flagged as such to key users. Key users are advised of substantial changes to
methods that affect consistency with previously reported information. Consistency will
be facilitated through the information infrastructure (e.g. through Tableau).
4.6 Methods used to produce information are understood and documented
Understanding how information is produced sheds light on the quality of SSC’s
information
Both the methods and classifications used in producing the information and measures
of the accuracy of the data (e.g. sample counts) should be documented.
Documentation is regularly reviewed and updated. Its level of detail suits
the needs of its intended audience. Documentation should be
standardised across SSC where possible.
2208917_6.docx
PROTOCOL 5: We share an information language
5.1 Common information standards are used to manage SSC information
SSC works to apply common frameworks, classification, derivations and metadata to
ensure that information has the same meaning across the organisation and that
separate datasets can be related to each other.
- Frameworks are a logical structure for organising complex information (e.g.
National Accounts)
- Classifications organise data by grouping similar items into understandable
categories (e.g. Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of
Occupations ANZSCO)
- Derivations are standardised ways to calculate one variable from another (e.g.
gender pay gap)
- Metadata is information that helps provide context around data (e.g. response
rates)
At SSC, our core framework looks at the varying dimensions of performance which can
be aggregated and disaggregated between CE, agency, sector and system. These
common standards will be incorporated in all new survey and administrative data
collections. They should be incorporated into existing data collections during major
revisions or upgrades to minimise costs.
SIT will be data custodians for information frameworks, standards, classifications. SIT
will ensure that this common information language is embedded into SCC practice
through Tableau and documented into the Data Architecture.
5.2 SSC uses national and international information standards where possible
To facilitate meaningful comparisons between agencies, sectors and countries, SSC
information frameworks, classifications and derivations should align wherever possible
with existing system, national and international standards.
SIT can advise on whether there are relevant existing information frameworks,
classifications and derivations.
5.3 SSC promotes common information standards across the system
SSC works cooperatively with other agencies in the development of common
information frameworks, standards, classifications and derivations.
SSC documents its common information frameworks, standards, classifications and
derivations and makes them available to other agencies, and supports other agencies
to use them.
2208917_6.docx
PROTOCOL 6: We use our information wisely
6.1 Information infrastructure assists with turning data into insight
SSC has a package of state of art tools (Tableau, R) that can turn data into insight.
The SIT team can advise on using these tools.
6.2 Processes get the right information to the right people at the right time
Information supplied meets user needs, in terms of substance and timeliness.
Published information is secure before it is released (refer to the Release Guidelines).
Information requests should come directly from users or should be put in writing.
RESOURCE: Release Guidelines
6.3 Published information is presented clearly and supported by analysis
SSC information is objective. Conclusions are supported by analysis.
6.4 Published information is open and accessible
SSC information meets its Open Government obligations. Anyone can freely access,
use, modify, and share SSC published information, detailed information is released
onto open.govt.nz. Published information is made available to all at the same time,
where possible.
RESOURCE:
Declaration on Open and Transparent Government
6.5 Published information is understandable
Information is presented clearly and simply, with easily understandable conclusions.
This can be achieved through written commentary, maps, graphs and statistical tables.
These should follow best practice so that they are easy to read and do not mislead.
The decisions behind the type of commentary and analysis provided should be
reasonable. Judgement is used to tailor the presentation of SSC published information
to our targeted users. Information that is published for transparency purposes
communicates key results in straightforward terms for the wider public.
As much detail as is reliable and practicable is made available, subject to
confidentiality constraints. To encourage comparative analysis and to provide context,
dissemination should include background information on metadata, trends and links to
related information. Recurring information releases are delivered in consistent formats.
When SSC reuses data collected by others, credit is given to the original data source.
6.6 Significant errors in published information are corrected quickly
All published errors are handled in a standard manner consistent with their significance
and revised when necessary. Revisions practice is covered in the Release Guidelines.
2208917_6.docx
link to page 11
SSC INFORMATION
RELEASE PROTOCOLS
These protocols formalise governance around the public release of information from the
Commission.
1
High value information is published where possible
•
SSC meet’s its obligation under the Declaration on Open and Transparent
Government to actively release high value public information. High value public
information:
o
“Is publicly-funded data, which when re-used contributes to economic,
social, cultural or environmental growth, illustrates government’s
performance, and contributes to greater government efficiencies through
improved information sharing. Public data is non-personal and unrestricted
data.”
1
o
Should be determined from the public’s point of view. OIA requests can help
SSC identify its high value public information.
•
To support this obligation, SSC follows the New Zealand Data and Information
Management Principles:
o Information is open, unless restricted by OIA or other policy.
o The withholding provisions of the OIA are useful guidelines when
considering whether to release information (see SSC’s
Official
Information Act (OIA) Guidelines):
–
protect New Zealand’s security
–
protect the privacy of natural persons
–
protect information where making it available would be likely to
unreasonably prejudice a person’s commercial position
–
protect information that is subject to an obligation of confidence
–
avoid prejudice to health and safety
–
maintain the constitutional conventions that protect the
confidentiality of advice tendered by Ministers of the Crown and
officials
–
maintain the effective conduct of public affairs through the free
and frank expression of opinions
–
maintain legal professional privilege, or
–
enable a Minister or department to carry on negotiations without
prejudice or disadvantage
o
Information is released proactively and readily available online
1
https://www.ict.govt.nz/guidance-and-resources/open-government/community-sector/
1
2310851_1.docx
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
o
Information is free where possible
o
Information is released in a form that makes it easily reusable (i.e. most
detail possible, machine readable, with metadata
•
To support regular publicly released information should have planned release
dates scheduled in the Proactive Release Programme.
•
SSC shares high value system information with agencies to support system
performance.
2
Published information is well managed
•
Published information has been managed under SSC’s
Information Management
Protocols, to ensure that:
o
Published information is trusted and authoritative (i.e. accurate, relevant,
timely, consistent and without bias)
o
Personal, confidential and classified information has been protected.
–
SSC’s
Confidentiality Guidelines provide guidance on how
information privacy and security can been maintained. These are
consistent with Privacy Act requirements and have been
developed in consultation with Statistics NZ. The SIT can help
with applying the Guidelines.
•
Quantitative information is checked before release to ensure its accuracy.
o
Published information accurately describes the reality it represents. Reports
that will be published or ministerial briefings need to have any quantitative
information checked by someone with the requisite knowledge, and need to
be discussed with SIT, if they substantially rely on quantitative information.
3
Published information is secure before release
•
Access is restricted to specified individuals or agencies prior to public release.
These are:
o
Those directly involved it is production
o
Ministers
o
System leaders
o
Select Committees
o
Information provided early for agency Annual Report publication timelines
o
Agencies, who provide the raw data, can access their own information along
with any system benchmark information
•
All others enjoy equal access to published information. It is made available to all at
the same time.
4
Revisions are managed openly and transparently
•
Published errors are handled in a standard manner consistent with their
significance and revised when necessary. All errors in SSC published information
need to be reported to the tier three manager responsible for that information. The
tier three manager should classify the error as either:
2310851_1.docx
UNCLASSIFIED
2
UNCLASSIFIED
o
An error that significantly alters the meaning of the previously published
information. Tier two manager needs to be informed. This needs to be
revised on the website as soon as possible. Users need to be identified as
soon as possible.
o
Errors that do not significantly alter the meaning of the published information
may be revised with the next regular information release, or if in an irregular
release, when it is convenient to SSC to do so.
o
Errors that do not alter the meaning of published information and that will
have very little or no impact on users. These errors can be ignored (revisions
which are frequent and trivial will undermine user confidence).
•
For each major information release, we publish and maintain a general statement
describing SSC revision practice.
•
Users should know when planned revisions are due and be aware of them as they
arise. Scheduled revisions are managed systematically, pre-announced and are
reflected in communication plans.
•
All revisions should be accompanied by documentation which explains their
nature, provides good analysis of the differences between the original and revised
information and explains the effect on any previously published commentary or
interpretation.
2310851_1.docx
UNCLASSIFIED
3
State Services Commission (SSC)
Information Collection Guidelines
__________________________________________________
These guidelines set out our practice around information collections at SSC and should be used
in conjunction with the information management and release protocols and the other resources
provided in this document.
1. Roles and responsibilities are adhered to
• All staff have a duty to take reasonable care of sensitive information provided to them,
this can be physically, electronically or even verbally.
• SSC staff should know their
responsibilities with SSC information and their obligations
to protect confidentiality and privacy.
• Prior to being granted access to sensitive strategic information, staff need to
acknowledge the rules set by the data steward.
2. Information is collected to meet a specific purpose
• The need for new information should be outlined with clear objectives before any data
collection is implemented.
• The value of the data SSC collects is understood and weighed against the cost of
collection.
• Information is collected for specific purposes and used as intended, in a way that aligns
with the permissions the data owner has provided (in accordance with t
he SSC privacy
policy and the information privacy principles of th
e Privacy Act 1993).
o
For current collections - if the permissions are unknown it is our responsibility to
identify what the permissions are before sharing or publishing any information or
analysis.
• Personal, confidential and classified information is protected and respondents
understand their rights and obligations in providing information.
3. Our information is well managed
• All information strategic or non-strategic needs to be managed well.
• SSC need to determine if the information is meets t
he definition of strategic information.
• New strategic information collections require LT approval. SIT can help input into the
decision paper for LT.
• All strategic information needs to be managed in accordance with Information
Management & Release Protocols. However not all strategic information needs to be
brought into the managed information environment. Data that is not built into this
environment will likely be stored the document management system (iManage).
• SIT will consider incorporating a new information collection into the managed data
environment based on a number of considerations. SIT may incorporate a collection into
the environment if:
o
The information is ‘strategic Information’
o
The collection will be repeated regularly
o
The information could be used to link with other data sources
2273557_3.docx
UN-CLASSIFIED
1
• SIT are unlikely to incorporate a collection into their environment if:
o
The information is corporate information
o
The information is ‘strategic information’ and the collection is an ad-hoc one off
o
The nature of the information is not strategic
• If the information is not strategic, SIT can still provide advice and support to ensure
information is well managed.
• When investing in a new collection, storage or administrative systems, SSC and SIT
need to ensure it is compatible with the current environment.
• When information needs have been defined and the collection is approved a data
custodian from SIT will work closely with the business owner (or data steward)
throughout the project. For more information about these terms see section 1.2 of the
Information Management Protocols.
4. New collections are well designed
• SSC teams should come talk to SIT if the need for new information has been identified
• SSC need to manage information collections well – this means information is managed
efficiently, effectively and can be trusted as being accurate.
o
Designing information collections is the first steps in our process and it is important
SSC teams talk to SIT at this stage so SIT can help design and develop tools that
are fit for purpose.
• SIT will approach SSC teams to review their information needs every two years,
including reassessing current collections.
5. Information collections are implemented in a respondent-friendly manner
• SSC teams should talk to SIT before asking for information from agencies or individuals
as the information may already be captured (and we should never ask for the same
information more than once).
• If SIT do not have the required information, we need to consider:
o
The individual providing the data and how much work is involved in producing it.
The information should be readily accessible to the respondent.
- Data should always be collected from the most appropriate source.
- It may be more efficient and less intrusive to collect the information through a
third party.
o
The best tool to capture the information in a respondent-friendly manner (e.g. Excel,
survey monkey or other option)
o
How the information will be used and the questions it will answer, to ensure the right
data is captured.
o
Respondent-friendly language is used and statistical jargon is avoided – SIT can
provide advice on questionnaire wording.
o
Any information standards we use – SIT can provide advice on current standards,
classifications and derivations.
o
How frequently we should ask for the information.
- The data needs to be relevant enough to meet the information needs, however
the frequency of a data collection should be weighed with the burden placed on
respondents and cost of collecting the data.
2273557_3.docx
UN-CLASSIFIED
2
link to page 18
6.
Appropriate collection channels are used and collected data is validated
• Identifying the right channel to collect data
o
The transfer of data needs to take place in a secure manner.
o
Minimising the burden placed on respondents, should be considered when
determining the right channel.
• The channels available include:
o
Less mature channels:
- Electronically – Email attachment.
- Physical Transfer – USB drives, Iron Keys, CDs
o
If the information is sensitive, additional security measures should be put in place
such as password-protected files.
• More mature channels:
o
Secure portals that require data submission:
- Survey Monkey
- Next Cloud
- CFISnet
• Most mature channel:
o
Accessible Systems (API)
• More information about each of these channels can be found i
n Appendix 1 at the end
of these information collection procedures.
• New tools for collecting information should be tested thoroughly before implementation
to ensure they can work within our managed environment and that any bugs are found
and fixed.
7. Collection Maturity Model
Less Mature
More Mature
Most Mature
Manual input and
Automated data collection
checking of Raw Data
& validation
Manual integration with
Data is integrated with
other data sources for
other data sources on
analysis
collection
Raw data exists in multiple
Central source of
places, no single source of
truth, protections
truth
against data loss
Data stored in database
Calculations hard to trace
Clear transparent
back and repeat
calculation processes
Automated calculations
Data collection is
Data collection is owned
Data collection is
automated, minimal
by the business unit
centralised
maintenance required
• Criteria to assist in vehicle selection:
o
Repetitive – is the data collection going to be repeated? If yes, more mature
methods are desirable.
2273557_3.docx
UN-CLASSIFIED
3
o
Content likeliness to change – will content potentially substantially change? If yes,
more mature methods provide less value.
o
Analysis complexity – is analysis time consuming and / or difficult to understand? If
yes, more mature methods are desirable.
o
Security – is data sensitive? If yes, more mature methods are desirable.
o
Turnaround time – Is speed of collection and analysis important? If yes, more
mature methods are desirable.
• Validating the data we collect:
o
When information is collected the data needs to be validated to ensure:
- The data has been collected as intended and is consistent with other instances
of the collection (if the information is collected regularly).
- Any erroneous data is amended in a consistent way.
• To validate the data:
o
Build in validation rules.
o
Check the data has been collected correctly (the correct template and data types).
o
Check for outliers in the first instance – Any specific values that do not look correct
should be checked with the data provider, if the value is incorrect, the data needs to
be updated.
o
Additional checks should be completed as the information is analysed such as:
- Changes over time – if there are large differences this may be due to an error
in the data; otherwise determine the reasons for the change.
- Large differences compared with other respondents.
It is also important to note if any information is going to be released to the public (regardless
of where the collection is managed) needs to be checked and t
he Information Release
Guidelines should be adhered to. – SIT complete checks to ensure the information we
release is accurate and confidential.
8. Collections are reviewed regularly:
• Regular collections are reviewed periodically to establish whether:
o
we can improve the method of collection
o
the information is still necessary
o
other appropriate data sources have become available
o
the views of respondents and users of data are being taken into account
o
variables are used effectively and that only necessary information is collected
Related Guidance:
Information Strategy Diagram
Information Management & Release Policy
Information Management Protocols
Information Release Guidelines
Information Confidentiality Guidelines
2273557_3.docx
UN-CLASSIFIED
4
I nformation Roles and Responsibilities
SSC
Privacy Policy
SSC OIA Guidelines
Appendix 1. Collection Channels
More mature channels:
•
Secure portals that require data submission:
o
Survey Monkey - Surveys are created in Survey Monkey and the data captured from
respondents is securely stored on the Survey Monkey server. The data is owned
and administered by the survey creator, however Survey Monkey do have the right
to access the survey data to provide the survey creator and respondents support.
Survey Monkey also have the right to share the information you capture in some
cases (such as if they obtain your consent or if they aggregate or de-identify the
information).
Survey Monkey allows the survey creator to control who completes the survey.
Survey Monkey is a good option for collecting information from a number of
individuals based on specific questions identified to answer an information need.
This option would be preferred to collecting the data electronically or physically from
each individual and collating the responses together which would be very time
consuming.
o
Next Cloud - Next cloud can be used for sharing information by loading the data into
next cloud and setting up access for users you want to share the information with.
The users’ username and password should be sent via email independently of the
link to the next cloud file.
o
CFISnet - CFISnet is used to collect confidential data in a secure manner. The data
is uploaded into a CASS managed database once the sender has logged in to
RealMe to verify their identity for security purposes. This option has been set up for
regular confidential data collection.
CFISnet is used to collect the HRC data and is the right tool to collect this data
because it is a secure file transfer process for large sensitive files.
Most mature channel:
•
Accessible Systems
o
These are systems that don’t require manual steps by users to submit data e.g. APIs
that developers can access programmatically. Examples of this include the SAP
API for Talent Exchange data, the DIA Govt. A-Z directory API for agency and
ministerial contact information.
Channels such as CFISnet and APIs would only be used for Strategic Information and
managed by SIT.
2273557_3.docx
UN-CLASSIFIED
5
Information Release Confidentiality Guidelines
The release guidelines state that Te Kawa Mataaho Public Service Commission (TKM) should
release high value information where possible, while also protecting personal information. These
guidelines make this possible by al owing as much high value information available for release,
while ensuring that it is:
• not in a form that could reasonably expected to identity an individual, or
• at a level of aggregation where the information is still informative.
The guidelines are consistent with Privacy Act requirements and were developed in consultation
with Stats NZ (see Stats NZ’
s Data Confidentiality report for more detail).
The guidelines apply to:
• all strategic information
• any statistical information that contains private or confidential information.
1.
Roles and responsibilities are adhered to
• Al staff have a duty to take reasonable care of sensitive information provided to them,
this can be physical y, electronical y or even verbal y.
• TKM staff should know thei
r responsibilities with TKM information and their obligations to
protect confidentiality and privacy.
• Prior to being granted access to sensitive strategic information, staff need to acknowledge
the rules set by the data steward.
2.
Use of confidential data within TKM
• Even if information is not going to be disclosed publicly, or external to TKM, privacy and
confidentiality should be maintained.
• Information should be provided to users of the information at the highest level of
aggregation, and/or anonymised, while stil being informative for the purposes of the
user.
• When providing information to users that is private or confidential in nature, you should
inform the user of this, and if necessary ensure that they know their roles and
responsibilities.
3.
Information release rules
• Al users of information should fol ow the release rules provided in Tables 1 and 2 below.
The release rules provide statistical advice on aggregation, suppression and counts.
• Information release rules apply to al personal information, which are outlined in table 3.
• TKM can choose, in the following circumstances, not to apply the rules:
o When suppling information back to the original supplier of the data. For example,
agency workforce information back to the HR team of that agency.
| 1
o If information is already public or can be easily ascertained by a member of the
public. For example, the gender of senior leadership team members.
o When reporting information that is organisational, rather than personal, in nature.
For example, counts at an agency by, job title or occupation, level. See table 3 for
examples of personal information.
•
Note Stats NZ advises that gender pay gaps are not statistical y robust for groups of fewer
than 20 men and 20 women. Gender pay gaps for smaller groups can be released, if they
meet the other rules in these guidelines and the release is accompanied by reference to
this information not being statistical y robust according to Stats NZ.
• Note that Te Kawa Mataaho has an agreement with GCSB and NZSIS to not release any
information col ected in the Workforce Data, beyond that published in thes
e three tables.
Table 1 – TKM Information Release Rules
Counts (e.g.
Magnitudes (e.g. Salary, Sick
Magnitudes (e.g.
Headcount, FTEs)
Leave) Means & totals
Salary, Sick
Leave) Medians &
percentiles
Full
Suppress cel s with
Suppress cel s with counts below Apply table 2.
coverage
counts below ‘4’ (this
‘4’ (this takes the possibility of
(e.g.
takes the possibility of
collusion into account). Make
Workforce collusion into account).
them appear like cells with zero
Data
Make them appear like
counts (i.e. either with a zero or
collection) cel s with zero counts
by leaving blank).
(i.e. either with a zero or Round magnitude values to an
by leaving blank).
appropriate level. For example,
Or
round average salary to the
Apply random rounding nearest $100, round average
to base 3 by using this
tenure, age and sick leave to one
workbook. Note any use decimal place. Percentages
of random rounding.
should be calculated using
Totals and percentages
rounded numbers.
should be calculated
Additional rule if needed
using rounded numbers. Suppress cel s with counts below
Additional rule if
‘10’ in the fol owing
needed
circumstances:
Apply both rules if many The use of multiple variables (e.g.
tables are being
occupation by department) or
produced that may
detailed variables (e, g.
mean values can be
occupation at very detailed
determined by looking
levels) means the risk of
across tables or a highly identifying an individual’s
sensitive variable is
information is high and the value
involved (e.g. income).
is highly sensitive (e.g. income).
| 2
Sample
Kiwis Count rules are about ensuring robustness of results, rather than
surveys
confidentiality. The smal size of the Kiwis Count survey means that it is very
(e.g. Kiwis
unlikely that an individual can be identified. Kiwis Count unit record data is
Count)
published on the TKM website after detailed regional council information is
removed.
Results for questions with unweighted sample counts of less than 25 are
suppressed with a ‘s’ due to potential y high margins of error.
Results for questions with unweighted sample counts of less than 50 (i.e. those
answered by less than 50 people) are released but are flagged that they may be
subject to high margins of error due to smal samples.
Table 2 – TKM Information Release Rules for Magnitude Medians and Percentiles
Percentile
Minimum count needed overall
1st
500
5th
100
10th
50
25th
20
50th (median)
10
75th
20
90th
50
95th
100
99th
500
Table 3 – Workforce Data person-level variables: Personal Information?
Variable
Personal information?
Gender
No for Male. Female
(personal, but not private)
Yes for Another Gender
Ethnicity
Yes
Date of Birth / Age
Yes
Occupation / Job Title
No
Department / Business Unit
No
Status – Current employee / Seconded /
No
Previous employee
Status – On Parental Leave / On other LWOP
Yes
Salary
Yes
Full-time Equivalent / Part-time
No
Contract Term (Permanent or fixed-term)
No
Tenure / Start or end date
No
Termination reason
Yes
Region
No
Management tier
No
Sick and domestic leave taken
Yes
| 3
Document Outline